Edwin F. Harding

Also known as: Edwin Foster Harding — the full name of the reference record · General Harding — the official history's styling at the Buna front · The Red Arrow's first wartime commander — the descriptive reading of his 1942 tenure ([Wikipedia — 32nd Infantry Division](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/32nd_Infantry_Division_(United_States) "32nd Infantry Division (United States) — Wikipedia"))

History

Definition

Edwin F. Harding — Edwin Foster Harding, September 18, 1886, Franklin, Ohio – June 5, 1970, Franklin, Ohio — was a major general of the United States Army who commanded the 32nd Infantry Division, the Wisconsin-Michigan National Guard “Red Arrow” division, from early 1942 through the opening weeks of the Battle of Buna–Gona in Papua — the first U.S. Army division to fight the Japanese in World War II — until his relief on December 2, 1942, when Robert L. Eichelberger, sent by Douglas MacArthur with the order “take Buna or don’t come back alive,” replaced him at the front. (Wikipedia — Edwin F. Harding, Wikipedia — 32nd Infantry Division, Milner — Victory in Papua, ch. XI) A West Pointer of the class of 1909 — the class of Patton, Devers, Simpson, and Eichelberger himself — Harding had spent the interwar years as the Infantry School’s chief of publications, editing the Army’s influential Infantry in Battle under George C. Marshall, and arrived at division command with the record of a doctrinal specialist rather than a field commander. (Wikipedia — Edwin F. Harding)

The relief is the act the record keeps, but the Philippine connection of his division runs the other way: the 32nd that stalled under Harding at Buna was rebuilt in Australia, climbed the New Guinea campaign’s ladder under William H. Gill — the command succession this wiki’s 32nd Division and William H. Gill entries carry — and returned to liberate Leyte in November 1944 and Luzon from January 1945, ending the war with 654 days of combat, eleven Medals of Honor, the Philippine Presidential Unit Citation, and Yamashita’s surrender staged in its own mountain sector. (Wikipedia — 32nd Infantry Division, Wikipedia — Edwin F. Harding) Buna, the campaign that opened the Army’s ground war against Japan, was the first step of MacArthur’s road back to the Philippines — fought by a division whose command Harding held and lost.

Identities

Source Type Identity
Wikipedia Edwin F. Harding (verified this session)
Wikidata Edwin F. Harding (Q5346405) — “U.S. Army general of World War II, commanded 32nd Infantry Division” (verified this session via the search API) (Wikidata — Q5346405)
DBpedia Edwin_F._Harding — resource resolves at the data endpoint, label “Edwin F. Harding”, typed MilitaryPerson; 1886-09-18 to 1970-06-05; commanded 32nd Infantry Division Feb–Dec 1942; Battle of Buna–Gona (verified this session) (DBpedia — Edwin F. Harding)
ProductOntology N/A
Wiktionary Harding — proper noun, English and Irish surname from the given name Hardy or Germanic hard compounds; the family-name headword for this subject (headword verified this session) (Wiktionary — Harding)
Library of Congress Subject Headings (LCSH) N/A — id.loc.gov unreachable this session (connect timeout)
MeSH N/A
NCBI Taxonomy N/A
AGROVOC N/A
Google Scholar Edwin F. Harding major general 32nd Infantry Division Red Arrow Wisconsin Michigan National Guard West Point 1909 Infantry in Battle Marshall Buna Gona Papua 1942 relief Eichelberger MacArthur Willoughby Waldron Kapa Kapa Owen Stanley Port Moresby Panama Mobile Force Antilles Department Historical Division
ConceptNet N/A — ConceptNet API unreachable this session (connect timeout)
OpenCyc N/A

Also Known As

  • Edwin Foster Harding — the full name of the reference record
  • General Harding — the official history’s styling at the Buna front
  • The Red Arrow’s first wartime commander — the descriptive reading of his 1942 tenure (Wikipedia — 32nd Infantry Division)

Examples and Analogies

  • The editor who had to fight his book: the man who edited Infantry in Battle, the Infantry School manual of maneuver doctrine, commanded a division forced to attack without tanks, with one 25-pounder battery in support, across a swamp front his own doctrine would have refused — the gap between textbook and terrain that December 1942 exposed. (Wikipedia — Edwin F. Harding)
  • A relief with a script: the December 2 scene in Eichelberger’s tent — Harding: “You were probably sent here to get heads, maybe mine is one of them. If so, it is on the block”; Eichelberger naming Waldron — is the Pacific war’s most quoted command change, preserved in the official history nearly verbatim. (Milner — Victory in Papua, ch. XI)
  • Verified service data (each item to its carrier):
  • Life: born September 18, 1886, Franklin, Ohio; died June 5, 1970, Franklin, Ohio, of cardiac arrest at 83 (Wikipedia — Edwin F. Harding)
  • Commission: West Point appointment secured by Secretary of War William Howard Taft; graduated 1909, 74th in the class — behind Patton (46th), Eichelberger (68th), and Devers (39th) (Wikipedia — Edwin F. Harding)
  • Interwar: Infantry School instructor in charge of publications under Marshall; editor of Infantry in Battle; colonel commanding the 27th Infantry Regiment in 1938 — the Schofield Barracks regiment this wiki’s William H. Gill entry records Gill briefly commanding that same year; brigadier general and assistant commander, 9th Infantry Division, 1941 (Wikipedia — Edwin F. Harding)
  • Division command: the 32nd Infantry Division from early 1942 — the divisional register carries March 1942, the biographical and DBpedia records February — to December 2, 1942; his first field command (Wikipedia — 32nd Infantry Division, Wikipedia — Edwin F. Harding, DBpedia — Edwin F. Harding)
  • Papua: division ordered to New Guinea September 1942; the Kapa Kapa march and the airlift over the Owen Stanleys put his regiments at Buna; tasked with the attack of November 19, 1942; intelligence estimated roughly 1,000 weak defenders; nearly killed before the assault when Japanese aircraft destroyed the trawler carrying his supplies (Wikipedia — Edwin F. Harding, Wikipedia — 32nd Infantry Division)
  • Relief: Colonel Larr’s adverse report November 27–28; Eichelberger arrived November 30 and assumed command of U.S. troops in the Buna Area at 1300 on December 1; Harding relieved December 2, 1942; succeeded by Waldron (wounded December 5), Byers (wounded), then Eichelberger himself from December 15, and Gill from February 1943 (Milner — Victory in Papua, ch. XI, Wikipedia — 32nd Infantry Division)
  • After: commander, Panama Mobile Force (1943); commander, Antilles Department (1944); director of the War Department’s Historical Division (1945), submitting on December 18, 1945 the plan for the Army’s approximately 120-volume World War II history; retired 1946 after 37 years’ service (Wikipedia — Edwin F. Harding)
  • Awards: Silver Star, Legion of Merit, Army Commendation Medal (Wikipedia — Edwin F. Harding)

Usage Scenarios

1. Working the Buna–Gona Command Record

Harding fixes the American half of the campaign’s command question — he commanded the division into the battle, Eichelberger directed it from December 2 — and the policing note this wiki’s Battle of Buna–Gona entry carries: the battle was Harding’s and Eichelberger’s fight, not Gill’s. (Milner — Victory in Papua, ch. XI, Wikipedia — 32nd Infantry Division)

2. Citing MacArthur’s Command Interventions

The Government House veranda exchange of November 30, 1942 — MacArthur “never been so humiliated in my life,” the “take Buna or don’t come back alive” ultimatum, and the order to relieve Harding and his subordinates “or I will relieve them myself and you too” — is the standard document of MacArthur’s theater-level command style. (Milner — Victory in Papua, ch. XI)

3. Tracing Doctrine Into Battle

The Infantry in Battle editor’s Buna command is the case study of interwar doctrine meeting jungle warfare — undertrained troops, coconut-log bunkers the aerial reconnaissance had dismissed, and logistics that failed forward of the airdrops, the gap the official history documents in the division’s stalling November. (Wikipedia — Edwin F. Harding, Milner — Victory in Papua, ch. XI)

4. Philippine Liberation Commemoration

The division Harding first took to war became the formation that took Limón on Leyte, broke the Yamashita line, landed at Lingayen on January 27, 1945, fought the Villa Verde Trail, and accepted the Shobu Group’s surrender at Kiangan on September 2, 1945 — the arc this wiki’s 32nd Division entry carries as the Red Arrow’s Philippine culmination. (Wikipedia — 32nd Infantry Division)

5. Studying the Army’s Official History Program

His postwar directorship of the Historical Division — the December 18, 1945 plan for the roughly 120-volume U.S. Army in World War II series, the series whose Papua and Triumph in the Philippines volumes this wiki cites — makes Harding the organizer of the very record his relief appears in. (Wikipedia — Edwin F. Harding)

Strategies

  • Edit the doctrine, then command by it: the Infantry School publications method — battle lessons converted into manual doctrine — was the specialty MacArthur’s army gave a division in crisis, and the record of his Buna decisions is read against that doctrinal pedigree. (Wikipedia — Edwin F. Harding)
  • Defend the regimental commanders: Harding refused Sutherland’s demand to relieve Colonels Mott and Hale, insisting his commanders “deserved to be decorated not relieved” — a loyalty that made his own relief the price, and the official history’s measure of the man. (Milner — Victory in Papua, ch. XI)
  • Accept the verdict on the block: his tent-scene acquiescence — offering his own head rather than his colonels’ — handed the division to Waldron without a command crisis at the front, the orderly relief the situation required. (Milner — Victory in Papua, ch. XI)
  • Rebuild the record-keeping: the Historical Division directorship converted a relieved commander into the architect of the Army’s massive official history — the institutional strategy that produced the volumes the Pacific record rests on. (Wikipedia — Edwin F. Harding)

Security and Safety Measures

  • The division’s medical ledger: the troops Eichelberger inspected on December 2 were found exhausted, sick, and half-starved — a division of roughly 75 percent malarial sick lists in the campaign’s ledger — the force-protection failure the relief answered as much as any tactical one. (Milner — Victory in Papua, ch. XI, Wikipedia — 32nd Infantry Division)
  • Intelligence as a survival system: the pre-battle estimate of about 1,000 weak defenders behind “hasty” entrenchments cost the November assaults their shape — the bunker-and-garrison intelligence failure this wiki’s Battle of Buna–Gona entry documents. (Wikipedia — Edwin F. Harding)
  • Command succession as risk management: the relief began a week that cost the division two more commanders to wounds — Waldron and Byers — before Eichelberger took direct control; the succession chain is the campaign’s lesson in depth of command. (Wikipedia — 32nd Infantry Division)
  • For researchers: carry the command-start variance openly — March 1942 in the divisional register, February 1942 in the biographical and DBpedia records — and keep the commanders’ battles apart: Buna was Harding’s and Eichelberger’s; the 1943 rebuild, New Guinea ladder, and Philippine liberation were Gill’s. (Wikipedia — 32nd Infantry Division, DBpedia — Edwin F. Harding)

Historical Context

Harding came out of Franklin, Ohio, through Phillips Exeter and a West Point appointment secured by Secretary of War Taft, graduating in the class of 1909 that also produced Patton, Devers, Simpson, Fuller — and Eichelberger, his classmate and eventual reliever. The interwar Army made him a doctrinal editor: Marshall’s Infantry School put him in charge of publications, and Infantry in Battle — with its triangular-division lessons — bears his editorial hand. A 1938 colonel commanding the 27th Infantry, he made brigadier in 1941 as assistant commander of the 9th Division, then took the 32nd — his first field command — in early 1942. (Wikipedia — Edwin F. Harding)

The division he inherited was the Wisconsin-Michigan National Guard’s Red Arrow, inducted in October 1940, triangularized in February 1942, and sent to Australia that May as the first U.S. division to go overseas in a single convoy. Ordered to New Guinea in September, it crossed the Owen Stanleys by the Kapa Kapa march and by air, and on November 19 attacked the Buna beachheads with too little artillery, too little intelligence, and too little jungle training; by late November Port Moresby had judged the advance stalled. (Wikipedia — 32nd Infantry Division, Wikipedia — Edwin F. Harding)

December 2, 1942 decided his place in the record. MacArthur — who had told Eichelberger that Harding “had failed and the blame for what had happened was his” — obtained the relief; Eichelberger executed it in the tent exchange the official history preserves; and the division passed through Waldron and Byers to Eichelberger and then to Gill, under whom it fought the campaign’s ladder — Saidor, Aitape, Morotai — to Leyte, Limón, and the Lingayen landing of January 27, 1945, the Villa Verde Trail, and the Kiangan surrender in its own sector. (Milner — Victory in Papua, ch. XI, Wikipedia — 32nd Infantry Division) Harding’s own war continued in the rear echelons — Panama, the Antilles, and the Historical Division — before retirement in 1946 and death in his Ohio birthplace on June 5, 1970. (Wikipedia — Edwin F. Harding)

Challenges and Controversies

The Relief Verdict

Was Harding responsible for Buna’s stalling, or its scapegoat? The official history documents MacArthur’s verdict and Sutherland’s recommendation, and equally the extenuations the division’s ledger carries — terrain, disease, supply, and the intelligence failure about the bunkers — the standing argument this wiki’s Battle of Buna–Gona entry carries rather than resolves. (Milner — Victory in Papua, ch. XI, Wikipedia — Edwin F. Harding)

Haste From Port Moresby

MacArthur’s demands for speed, made without a front visit, compressed the November assaults and enlarged the casualty lists — the command-climate critique that frames any assessment of a division commander given weeks to do what the campaign took three months to do. (Milner — Victory in Papua, ch. XI)

The Classmate Geometry

Eichelberger, 68th to Harding’s 74th in the class of 1909, arrived to relieve a classmate under an ultimatum — a personal dimension the memoir literature has worked ever since, and one the official history’s verbatim tent scene keeps in view. (Milner — Victory in Papua, ch. XI, Wikipedia — Edwin F. Harding)

The Register Variances

Three variances travel with his name: the command start (February versus March 1942), the compression that hands Buna — or even the division’s Philippine battles — to Gill, and retellings that date the relief to January 1943. The controlling dates are: command from early 1942, relieved December 2, 1942, Gill’s command from February–March 1943. (Wikipedia — 32nd Infantry Division, DBpedia — Edwin F. Harding, Wikipedia — Edwin F. Harding)

Related Topic

References

  1. Edwin F. Harding — Wikipedia
  2. Edwin F. Harding (Q5346405) — Wikidata
  3. Edwin F. Harding — DBpedia (data endpoint)
  4. Harding — Wiktionary
  5. Milner, Victory in Papua, Chapter XI — U.S. Army in World War II, Center of Military History (HyperWar)
  6. 32nd Infantry Division (United States) — Wikipedia

Twenty Twenty-Five

Designed with WordPress