Tag: executive-orders

  • Expanded National Greening Program

    Definition

    The Expanded National Greening Program (ENGP) is the 2016–2028 continuation of the Philippines’ flagship reforestation undertaking, created by Executive Order No. 193 of November 12, 2015 — long-titled “Expanding the Coverage of the National Greening Program” and signed by President Benigno S. Aquino III. The order declared that “The coverage of the National Greening Program is hereby expanded to cover all the remaining unproductive, denuded and degraded forestlands” — an estimated 7.1 million hectares — extended implementation “from 2016 to 2028,” encouraged “All sectors, particularly the private sector” to participate, and gave the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) sixty days to issue implementing rules. (LawPhil — EO 193) The order rested its case on the FAO’s Global Forest Resources Assessment, which ranked the Philippines fifth worldwide in forest-area gain from 2010 to 2015. (LawPhil — EO 193, PIDS — NGP impact study)

    The expanded program inherits the original NGP’s machinery. That program — declared by Executive Order No. 26 of February 24, 2011, three weeks after Executive Order No. 23’s nationwide logging moratorium — was to “plant some 1.5 Billion trees covering about 1.5 Million hectares” of public land “for a period of six (6) years from 2011 to 2016,” through the DENR-chaired convergence with the Departments of Agriculture (DA) and Agrarian Reform (DAR). (LawPhil — EO 26, LawPhil — EO 23) The DENR’s own register styles the post-2015 program the Enhanced National Greening Program (E-NGP) — one of the naming variants this entry records — with priorities it states as “REHABILITATION OF 1.2 M HECTARES OF DENUDED FOREST LANDS BY 2022” and “MAINTENANCE AND PROTECTION OF EXISTING FORESTS.” (DENR R7 — Enhanced National Greening Program)

    Identities

    Source Type Identity
    Wikipedia N/A — no standalone article at “National Greening Program” or “Expanded National Greening Program” (title fetch returned 404 this session); the program is covered within Wikipedia’s Department of Environment and Natural Resources article, which describes the 2011–2016 greening as the department’s flagship project (Wikipedia — DENR)
    Wikidata N/A — entity search returned no item for either program name (verified this session)
    DBpedia N/A — dbpedia.org data endpoint unreachable this session (ETIMEDOUT)
    ProductOntology N/A
    Wiktionary reforestation — noun: “The act or process of replanting a forest, especially after clear-cutting” (the program’s field, not the program; headword verified this session) (Wiktionary — reforestation)
    Library of Congress Subject Headings (LCSH) N/A
    MeSH N/A — “reforestation” and “forestation” return no items in the MeSH database (search verified this session)
    NCBI Taxonomy N/A
    AGROVOC N/A — AGROVOC lookup endpoints unreachable this session
    Google Scholar Expanded National Greening Program ENGP E-NGP Enhanced National Greening Program EO 193 2015 2016 2028 7.1 million hectares DENR DA DAR convergence reforestation survival rate COA performance audit 88.17 percent 177441 hectares 47.22 billion falcata agroforestry people’s organizations
    ConceptNet N/A — ConceptNet API unreachable this session (HTTP 502)
    OpenCyc N/A

    Also Known As

    Examples and Analogies

    • From 1.5 million to 7.1 million hectares: where the original NGP set itself 1.5 million hectares in six years, the expansion set itself all the remaining degraded forestlands — estimated at 7.1 million — over thirteen, the same machinery aimed at nearly five times the acreage. (LawPhil — EO 26, LawPhil — EO 193)
    • The audit’s arithmetic: against a 1.5-million-hectare goal the Commission on Audit counted 177,441 hectares of forest-cover gain from 2011 to 2019 on ₱47.22 billion of spending — “a whopping 88.17 percent” of target missed — the arithmetic that defines the program’s contested reputation. (Inquirer — Reforestation fail)
    • Two ledgers for one forest: the planting reports — over 1.3 billion seedlings on more than 1.6 million hectares as of June 2016 — stand beside the audit’s verified 177,441 hectares; the first counts work done, the second counts forest that grew. (PIDS — NGP impact study, Inquirer — Reforestation fail)
    • Verified program data:
    • Expansion instrument: EO 193, signed November 12, 2015; coverage all remaining unproductive, denuded, and degraded forestlands estimated at 7.1 million hectares, 2016–2028; DENR rules within 60 days (LawPhil — EO 193)
    • Original program: EO 26 (February 24, 2011) — 1.5 billion trees on about 1.5 million hectares, 2011–2016, on forestlands, mangrove and protected areas, ancestral domains, reservations, urban areas, and abandoned mine sites; consolidated the Upland Development Program and Luntiang Pilipinas (LawPhil — EO 26)
    • Twin moratorium: EO 23 (February 1, 2011) — cutting ban in the natural and residual forests; DENR-chaired Anti-Illegal Logging Task Force; directive to develop the NGP through the DA–DENR–DAR Convergence Initiative (LawPhil — EO 23)
    • Planting ledger: ₱31 billion over five years per PIDS; as of June 2016 over 1.3 billion seedlings on more than 1.6 million hectares (113 percent of area target); 3.3 million jobs (PIDS — NGP impact study)
    • Audit ledger: 2013 examination reported April 2015 — ₱7.2 billion across ten regions judged a failure, completion as low as 20 percent of 17,697 hectares in Central Luzon; 2019 performance audit — 88.17 percent of the 2011–2019 target missed on ₱47.22 billion; budget halved from ₱5.15 billion (2018) to ₱2.60 billion (2019) (Inquirer — COA 2015, Inquirer — Reforestation fail)

    Usage Scenarios

    1. Reforesting Degraded Forestlands at Scale

    The core business is site development — seedling production, planting, and maintenance across the degraded estate the orders size at 7.1 million hectares, translated in DENR registers into targets like the 1.2 million hectares by 2022. (LawPhil — EO 193, DENR R7 — Enhanced National Greening Program)

    2. Governing by Convergence

    Implementers run the machinery the orders fixed: the DENR as chair and lead agency, the DA and DAR as partners, with DepEd, CHED, DSWD, DBM, LGUs, and the private sector enrolled. (LawPhil — EO 26, LawPhil — EO 193)

    3. Programming Budgets Against Targets

    Planners work the audited arithmetic — the ₱31-billion first phase, the ₱47.22-billion decade total, the post-audit halving of the appropriation — in sizing what the 2028 horizon can still buy. (PIDS — NGP impact study, Inquirer — Reforestation fail)

    4. Audit and Accountability Research

    Researchers use the ENGP as the Philippine case study in target-driven environmental programming: the COA findings for the critique, the PIDS impact study for the program-side economics. (Inquirer — COA 2015, Inquirer — Reforestation fail, PIDS — NGP impact study)

    Strategies

    • Extend what external assessment credits: EO 193 scaled the program on the FAO’s fifth-place forest-gain ranking — external validation as the warrant for a longer, larger commitment. (LawPhil — EO 193, PIDS — NGP impact study)
    • Converge departments, not just agencies: tying planting to the DA–DAR–DENR initiative rests on the premise that upland livelihood and tenure, not silviculture alone, decide whether trees survive. (LawPhil — EO 26)
    • Pair planting with policing: EO 23’s moratorium and task force made protection the planting program’s guardrail — the two-handed policy this wiki’s National Greening Program entry records. (LawPhil — EO 23)
    • Shift from target-driven to community-centered: the audit’s prescription — a strategy “more community-centered than target-driven,” with capacity-calibrated goals and trained people’s organizations — is the reform the expanded program inherited. (Inquirer — Reforestation fail)
    • Review the species mix: PIDS recommended revisiting species, spacing, incentives, and harvesting rights — answering the audit’s finding that falcata and agroforestry crops added less cover than assumed. (PIDS — NGP impact study, Inquirer — Reforestation fail)

    Security and Safety Measures

    • Survey, mapping, and planning before planting: the audits’ central safeguard finding — areas chosen without mapping proved non-plantable, and late-delivered seedlings were planted at the wrong end of the rainy season. (Inquirer — COA 2015)
    • Standing partner organizations: survival depends on identified people’s organizations to guard and monitor plantations; the 2013 audit found sites where none existed. (Inquirer — COA 2015)
    • Maintenance and protection as program pillars: the DENR register makes protection of existing forests a co-equal priority with rehabilitation — the design answer to survival-rate failure. (DENR R7 — Enhanced National Greening Program)
    • For researchers: cite the program by instrument — EO 26 (2011) for the NGP, EO 193 (2015) for the ENGP — and keep the ledgers distinct: the ₱7.2-billion findings belong to the 2013 examination, the 88.17-percent shortfall to the 2011–2019 record, the 1.6-million-hectare figure to the planting reports carried by PIDS. (LawPhil — EO 26, LawPhil — EO 193, Inquirer — COA 2015, PIDS — NGP impact study)

    Historical Context

    The program was born as one half of the 2011 forest policy: EO 23 declared the moratorium, seated the Anti-Illegal Logging Task Force, and directed the convergence to develop a greening program; EO 26 declared that program three weeks later, fixed the 1.5-billion-tree target, and consolidated the earlier efforts beneath it. (LawPhil — EO 23, LawPhil — EO 26)

    The first phase closed on divergent ledgers. The program side — carried by PIDS — reported 1.3 billion seedlings on 1.6 million hectares by June 2016, 3.3 million jobs, and income gains at three-fourths of site households, against persistent “low survival rate of trees planted and poor program monitoring.” (PIDS — NGP impact study) The audit side had judged the ₱7.2-billion, ten-region effort a failure in 2015, and the 2019 performance audit found 88.17 percent of the 2011–2019 target missed — part of the reported gain plausibly the logging ban’s natural growth — summed up in the commission’s phrase “Haste makes waste.” (Inquirer — COA 2015, Inquirer — Reforestation fail)

    The expansion bridged the two: EO 193, signed in November 2015 before the audits’ final verdicts, extended the program to 2028 over the 7.1 million degraded hectares, and the DENR’s registers still carry the E-NGP among the department’s priority programs — the departmental frame Wikipedia records as the 2011–2016 flagship project within the deforestation history this wiki’s Deforestation in the Philippines entry carries. (LawPhil — EO 193, DENR R7 — Enhanced National Greening Program, Wikipedia — DENR)

    Challenges and Controversies

    The Commission on Audit’s Verdicts

    The 2013 examination — non-plantable sites, mistimed planting, missing partners, deficient biddings — and the 2019 audit’s 88.17-percent miss on ₱47.22 billion form the standing critique; defenders answer with the planting ledger and the FAO ranking. (Inquirer — COA 2015, Inquirer — Reforestation fail, PIDS — NGP impact study)

    Survival and the Species Question

    Low sapling survival — worsened where 2018’s typhoons Ompong and Rosita struck — and a livelihood-driven mix of falcata, coffee, and cacao that “do not contribute to forest cover” in the audit’s finding remain the technical controversies; PIDS’s species-and-incentives recommendations mark the reform path. (Inquirer — Reforestation fail, PIDS — NGP impact study)

    Whose Hectares Count

    The 1.6-million-hectare planting report and the audit’s 177,441-hectare cover gain do not measure the same thing, and the gap — planting accomplished versus forest established, natural growth versus program effect — shadows every claim for either program. (PIDS — NGP impact study, Inquirer — Reforestation fail)

    A Program of Many Names

    “Expanded” (the order’s word), “Enhanced” (the DENR’s styling), and the abbreviations ENGP and E-NGP circulate together, and at least one DENR regional register renders EO 26’s six-year 2011–2016 window as “from CY 2011 to CY 2028” — a conflation the orders’ own texts correct. (LawPhil — EO 26, DENR R7 — Enhanced National Greening Program)

    Related Topic

    • National Greening Program
    • Executive Order No. 26 (2011)
    • Executive Order No. 23 (2011)
    • Executive Order No. 193 (2015)
    • Department of Environment and Natural Resources
    • Forest Management Bureau
    • Department of Agriculture
    • Department of Agrarian Reform
    • Commission on Audit
    • Philippine Institute for Development Studies
    • Deforestation in the Philippines
    • Reforestation
    • Kaingin
    • Illegal logging in the Philippines
    • People’s organizations
    • Food and Agriculture Organization
    • Typhoon Ompong
    • Typhoon Rosita

    References

    1. Executive Order No. 193, Expanding the Coverage of the National Greening Program (November 12, 2015) — The LawPhil Project
    2. Executive Order No. 26, Declaring an Interdepartmental Convergence Initiative for a National Greening Program (February 24, 2011) — The LawPhil Project
    3. Executive Order No. 23, Declaring a Moratorium on the Cutting and Harvesting of Timber in the Natural and Residual Forests and Creating the Anti-Illegal Logging Task Force (February 1, 2011) — The LawPhil Project
    4. Enhanced National Greening Program — DENR Region 7 (official website)
    5. PIDS study sees positive impact of greening program on economy and environment — Philippine Institute for Development Studies
    6. COA: P7B tree-planting project of DENR a failure — Inquirer News (April 24, 2015)
    7. Reforestation fail — Inquirer Opinion (January 9, 2020)
    8. Department of Environment and Natural Resources — Wikipedia
    9. reforestation — Wiktionary