Definition
The Rescission Act — the Rescission Act of 1946, Public Law 301 of the 79th Congress, approved February 18, 1946, 60 Stat. 6 (Philippine proviso at 60 Stat. 14), and now codified at 38 U.S.C. § 107 — is the United States statute that declared “service in the organized military forces of the Government of the Commonwealth of the Philippines,” while serving the United States armed forces under the military order of July 26, 1941, “shall not be deemed to be or to have been service in the military or naval forces of the United States” for the purposes of any law conferring rights, privileges, or benefits. (govinfo — 60 Stat. 6) Its effect was “to retroactively annul benefits to Filipino troops,” ahead of Philippine independence on July 4, 1946. (Wikipedia — Rescission Act) The Philippine clause is a proviso to the appropriation “Army of the Philippines, $200,000,000” in Title II of an act whose own short title is the “First Supplemental Surplus Appropriation Rescission Act, 1946”; a companion, the Second Supplemental (Public Law 391, May 27, 1946), extended the rule to the post-war Philippine Scouts. (govinfo — 60 Stat. 6, govinfo — 60 Stat. 221)
Only National Service Life Insurance contracts “heretofore entered into” and service-connected pensions survived, “paid at the rate of one Philippine peso for each dollar authorized” — a peso then worth fifty cents. (govinfo — 60 Stat. 6, VA History — Manila Loyalty Room) Congress replaced an estimated $3 billion in projected benefits with the single $200 million payment, which President Sergio Osmeña called “inadequate for the payment of the benefits it intends to confer”; the VA’s own history adds that the laws spared only “the 12,000 who had enlisted in the old Philippine Scouts.” (Wikipedia — Rescission Act, VA History — Manila Loyalty Room)
Identities
| Source Type | Identity |
|---|---|
| Wikipedia | Rescission Act — the canonical article title (Wikipedia — Rescission Act) |
| Wikidata | Rescission Act of 1946 (Q7314953) — “American law”; instance of Act of Congress (verified this session) (Wikidata — Q7314953) |
| DBpedia | Rescission_Act_of_1946 — sameAs Wikidata Q7314953 (verified this session at the data endpoint) (DBpedia — Rescission Act of 1946) |
| ProductOntology | Class: Rescission Act — class page live (verified this session) (ProductOntology — Rescission Act) |
| Wiktionary | rescission — noun, “An act of rescinding: removing, taking away, or taking back” (verified this session) (Wiktionary — rescission) |
| Library of Congress Subject Headings (LCSH) | Filipino Americans (sh85048212) — the community heading; no act-specific heading (LCSH — Filipino Americans) |
| MeSH | Veterans (D014728) — the population class; no act-specific descriptor (verified this session) (MeSH — D014728) |
| NCBI Taxonomy | N/A |
| AGROVOC | N/A |
| Google Scholar | Rescission Act of 1946 Public Law 79-301 60 Stat. 6 First Supplemental Surplus Appropriation Rescission Act Army of the Philippines 200,000,000 Commonwealth Army July 26 1941 Second Supplemental 79-391 new Philippine Scouts 38 U.S.C. 107 |
| ConceptNet | N/A |
| OpenCyc | N/A |
Also Known As
- Rescission Act of 1946 — the structured record’s label and the encyclopedia’s redirect (Wikidata — Q7314953)
- First Supplemental Surplus Appropriation Rescission Act, 1946 — the act’s own short title (Section 301) (govinfo — 60 Stat. 6)
- The Rescission Acts of 1946 — Congress’s own name for the pair, Public Laws 79-301 and 79-391 (govinfo — 38 U.S.C. 107)
Examples and Analogies
- The regular Scouts as the control group: the pre-war Philippine Scouts were United States soldiers and were never touched; the rescinded service was the Commonwealth Army’s, called into United States service by Roosevelt’s order of July 26, 1941. (VA History — Manila Loyalty Room, govinfo — P.L. 114-265)
- A proviso in a spending-cut bill: the clause that settled a generation of Filipino soldiers’ status rides on a line of the transfer schedule, moving funds from the appropriation “Ordnance Service and Supplies, Army.” (govinfo — 60 Stat. 6)
- Verified statutory data (each item to its carrier):
- Companion act: Chapter 271, H.R. 5604, Public Law 391, approved May 27, 1946, 60 Stat. 221; Scouts proviso at 60 Stat. 223–224 (govinfo — 60 Stat. 221)
- Codification: 38 U.S.C. § 107, “Certain service deemed not to be active service,” enacted in 1958; subsection (a) now includes “organized guerrilla forces under commanders appointed, designated, or subsequently recognized,” and payments are fixed at “$0.50 for each dollar authorized” (govinfo — 38 U.S.C. 107)
- Equity payments, 2009: Section 1002 of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act — a $198,000,000 “Filipino Veterans Equity Compensation Fund”; $15,000 to citizens, $9,000 to non-citizens; claims within one year (govinfo — 38 U.S.C. 107)
- Payout and recognition: “over $221 million in one-time FVECP payments to some 18,530 eligible veterans”; Congressional Gold Medal awarded October 25, 2017 (Inquirer — $214M, VA News — Gold Medal)
Usage Scenarios
1. Telling the Filipino Services Apart
Congress’s 2016 findings list five groups that served in the USAFFE — the Philippine Scouts, the Commonwealth Army, the new Philippine Scouts, attached civilians, and the “Guerrilla Services” — and its medal definition adds the First Filipino Infantry Regiment of this wiki’s Filipino Americans entry; the rescissions reached only the second, third, and fifth. (govinfo — P.L. 114-265, govinfo — 38 U.S.C. 107)
2. Tracing the Equity Movement
The partial restorations run from the 1990 naturalization right, through which “over 20,000” veterans became citizens, to VA health care for Filipino American veterans in 2003, the 2009 lump sums, and the 2017 medal — the sequence this wiki’s Filipino Americans entry reads as redress “with full equity never enacted.” (Wikipedia — Rescission Act)
3. Sizing the Philippine Claim
Philippine-side accounting follows the money home: a $192 million disability-compensation allocation for “approximately 15,000 beneficiaries” in 2012 and “over $6.5 million” in grant-in-aid to the Veterans Memorial Medical Center in nine years. (Inquirer — $214M)
Strategies
- Cap the liability with a single payment: against the VA’s estimate “that it would cost $3.2 billion to extend the GI Bill and other benefits to Filipino Veterans over their lifetimes” (the reference article says “$3 billion”), Congress substituted $200 million. (VA History — Manila Loyalty Room, Wikipedia — Rescission Act)
- Legislate through the appropriators: the measure was pushed by Senators Carl Hayden and Richard Russell Jr.; Resident Commissioner Carlos P. Romulo “spoke out against the legislation.” (Wikipedia — Rescission Act)
- Answer a claim with a release: the 2009 payment “shall be final, and shall constitute a complete release of any claim against the United States,” while the service is “recognized as active military service … to the extent provided in, this section.” (govinfo — 38 U.S.C. 107)
Security and Safety Measures
- Citizenship and residence change the rate: the half-rate rule “shall not apply” to specified compensation and survivors’ benefits paid to veterans who are citizens or permanent residents “residing in the United States.” (govinfo — 38 U.S.C. 107)
- Documentation is the real barrier: the Army “issued formal letters of recognition to 289 guerilla units” and validated 260,715 individual guerrillas, and VA screened claimants against the Manila “Loyalty Room.” (VA History — Manila Loyalty Room)
- For researchers: § 107 is the 1958 codification of the 1946 provisos, not a section the 1946 act amended, and “active service” is the Code’s later phrase, not the statute’s. (govinfo — 38 U.S.C. 107, govinfo — 60 Stat. 6)
Historical Context
The obligation began with the independence settlement: the 1934 law let the President call the Philippine forces into United States service, and on July 26, 1941 Roosevelt did so. (VA History — Manila Loyalty Room) The benefits question surfaced in 1942, when 24 Filipino soldiers applied for National Service Life Insurance and “VA issued an opinion stating these soldiers were eligible.” (VA History — Manila Loyalty Room)
The 1946 settlement reversed that reading: a first act on February 18, a second on May 27, independence on July 4. “Of the 66 countries allied with the United States during the war, only Filipinos were denied military benefits.” (govinfo — 60 Stat. 221, VA History — Manila Loyalty Room, Wikipedia — Rescission Act) Restoration came in slices, down to the Congressional Gold Medal awarded at the Capitol in 2017. (VA News — Gold Medal)
Challenges and Controversies
First or Second Supplemental?
The encyclopedia’s infobox — and the DBpedia record drawn from it — carries the long title and nickname of the Second Supplemental act while citing Public Law 79-301. The Statutes at Large settle it: 79-301 is the “First Supplemental Surplus Appropriation Rescission Act, 1946”; 79-391 is the “Second.” (Wikipedia — Rescission Act, govinfo — 60 Stat. 6, govinfo — 60 Stat. 221, DBpedia — Rescission Act of 1946)
How Many Served, and How Many Were Paid
The counts differ by carrier: “over 200,000” in the reference article, “approximately 250,000” by the VA’s account, 260,715 individually recognized guerrillas — against 42,755 equity claims filed and 18,960 granted. (Wikipedia — Rescission Act, VA News — Gold Medal, VA History — Manila Loyalty Room)
A Settlement, or Equity?
The 2009 payment was framed “as damages for human suffering,” yet it came wrapped in a release: “Acceptance of the payment would deny the payer any future benefits” — a settlement in lieu of full equity. (govinfo — 38 U.S.C. 107, Wikipedia — Rescission Act)
Related Topic
- Filipino Americans
- Filipino Repatriation Act of 1935
- Luce-Celler Act
- Tydings-McDuffie Act
- Philippine Scouts
- Sergio Osmeña
- 1st Filipino Infantry Regiment
- Veterans Memorial Medical Center
- Filipino Veterans Fairness Act
References
- Rescission Act — Wikipedia
- Public Law 301, 60 Stat. 6 — First Supplemental Surplus Appropriation Rescission Act, 1946 — govinfo
- Public Law 391, 60 Stat. 221 — Second Supplemental Surplus Appropriation Rescission Act, 1946 — govinfo
- 38 U.S.C. § 107 — Certain service deemed not to be active service — U.S. Code, 2023 Edition (govinfo)
- Object 99: Bank Check from Manila Loyalty Room — VA History
- Filipino Veterans of World War II Congressional Gold Medal Act, Public Law 114-265 — govinfo
- The Congressional Gold Medal Tribute to Filipino WWII Veterans — VA News
- Filipino veterans got $214M from US last year — Inquirer (February 3, 2012)
- Rescission Act of 1946 (Q7314953) — Wikidata
- Rescission Act of 1946 — DBpedia (data endpoint)
- Class: Rescission Act — Product Ontology
- rescission — Wiktionary
- Filipino Americans — Library of Congress Subject Headings (sh85048212)
- Veterans — MeSH Descriptor D014728