Sydney Rowell

Also known as: Lieutenant General Sir Sydney Fairbairn Rowell — the full rank and name of the reference record ([Wikipedia — Sydney Rowell](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sydney_Rowell "Sydney Rowell — Wikipedia")) · "Syd" — his nickname, and Vasey's whole warning to Morris: "Syd is coming" ([Wikipedia — Sydney Rowell](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sydney_Rowell "Sydney Rowell — Wikipedia")) · VX3 — his AIF service number

History

Definition

Sydney Rowell — Lieutenant General Sir Sydney Fairbairn Rowell, KBE, CB, born 15 December 1894 at Lockleys, South Australia, died 12 April 1975 at South Yarra, Victoria — was an Australian soldier who served as Chief of the General Staff from 17 April 1950 to 15 December 1954, the first Duntroon graduate to hold the post, and who is “best known as the commander who was dismissed in the Kokoda Track campaign.” (Wikipedia — Sydney Rowell, ADB — Rowell) One of the first cadets to enter Duntroon when it opened in 1911, he served the First World War in the 3rd Light Horse Regiment at Gallipoli, from which typhoid invalided him home for good, and rose between the wars through staff and British exchange postings. (Wikipedia — Sydney Rowell) In 1939 Blamey made him chief of staff — not commander — of the 6th Division, and then brigadier, general staff, of I Corps in Greece and Syria; in 1942 he commanded I Corps and, from August, New Guinea Force, until Blamey “dismissed Rowell” on 28 September 1942 and Herring was sent to succeed him. (Wikipedia — Sydney Rowell, ADB — Rowell)

The dismissal is why this wiki carries him: the first of the three reliefs — Rowell, Arnold Potts, Arthur Allen — that this wiki’s Kokoda Track Campaign entry registers as the “crisis of command.” (Wikipedia — Kokoda Track campaign) MacArthur “persuaded” Prime Minister John Curtin to send Blamey to New Guinea to “energise the situation”; Blamey took over New Guinea Force on 23 September, bypassed Rowell with an order at Milne Bay on the 25th, and dismissed him three days later. (Wikipedia — Kokoda Track campaign, ADB — Rowell)

Identities

Source Type Identity
Wikipedia Sydney Rowell — the canonical article title (Wikipedia — Sydney Rowell)
Wikidata Sydney Rowell (Q7660119) — “Australian general (1894–1975)”; alias Sydney Fairbairn Rowell (verified this session) (Wikidata — Q7660119)
DBpedia Sydney_Rowell — Person; born 1894-12-15, died 1975-04-12; service number VX3 (verified this session at the data endpoint) (DBpedia — Sydney Rowell)
ProductOntology Class: Sydney Rowell — class page live (verified this session) (ProductOntology — Sydney Rowell)
Wiktionary Rowell — proper noun, a surname; the general is not a headword (verified this session) (Wiktionary — Rowell)
Library of Congress Subject Headings (LCSH) N/A
MeSH N/A
NCBI Taxonomy N/A
AGROVOC N/A
Google Scholar Sydney Rowell lieutenant general Duntroon 3rd Light Horse Gallipoli typhoid Camberley 6th Division chief of staff I Corps Greece New Guinea Force Kokoda Blamey MacArthur Curtin dismissal 28 September 1942 Herring War Office Chief of the General Staff Full Circle
ConceptNet N/A
OpenCyc N/A

Also Known As

  • Lieutenant General Sir Sydney Fairbairn Rowell — the full rank and name of the reference record (Wikipedia — Sydney Rowell)
  • “Syd” — his nickname, and Vasey’s whole warning to Morris: “Syd is coming” (Wikipedia — Sydney Rowell)
  • VX3 — his AIF service number

Examples and Analogies

  • The Duntroon man who missed the war: of the cadets “134 commissioned in time to serve at the front, 42 were killed and 38 wounded”; pneumonia, a broken leg, and typhoid left Rowell, by the rule that an invalided regular could not again be posted overseas, still a lieutenant at the war’s end. (Wikipedia — Sydney Rowell)
  • The general who would not be a chief of staff: Rowell’s objection to Blamey’s arrival, the campaign article records, “was not to Blamey using his headquarters as much as the expectation that he (Rowell) was expected to be Blamey’s chief-of-staff” — and the headquarters subsequently operated much that way under Herring. (Wikipedia — Kokoda Track campaign)
  • Verified service data (each item to its carrier):
  • First World War: 3rd Light Horse Regiment; Anzac Cove 12 May 1915; evacuated with typhoid, November; home 20 January 1916; instructing at Duntroon to June 1917 (Wikipedia — Sydney Rowell, ADB — Rowell)
  • Interwar: captain 1920, major 1926, brevet lieutenant colonel 1935; Camberley 1925–26; 44th Division exchange 1935–37; Imperial Defence College; OBE 1938 (Wikipedia — Sydney Rowell)
  • Second World War: chief of staff, 6th Division, October 1939; brigadier, general staff, I Corps, 1940; Deputy Chief of the General Staff, August 1941; I Corps, 1942; New Guinea Force, August – 28 September 1942; Cairo from February 1943; War Office, London, to the end of 1945 (Wikipedia — Sydney Rowell, ADB — Rowell)
  • Postwar: Vice Chief of the General Staff, 8 January 1946 – 16 April 1950; Chief of the General Staff, 17 April 1950 – 15 December 1954; Korea in 1952 and 1953, the War Memorial’s photograph showing “Lieutenant General Sir Sydney Rowell, CGS” (Wikipedia — Sydney Rowell, AWM — photograph 044755)
  • Memoir: director of Elder, Smith & Co., 1954; Commonwealth Aircraft Corporation from 1956, chairman 1957–68; Full Circle (1974), “the only Chief of the General Staff to have done so” (Wikipedia — Sydney Rowell)

Usage Scenarios

1. Studying the Kokoda Crisis of Command

Rowell is the first of the campaign’s three sackings — Potts recalled by Rowell on 10 September, Rowell relieved on the 28th, Allen replaced in October — the sequence this wiki’s Arthur Allen and Thomas Blamey entries carry. (Wikipedia — Kokoda Track campaign)

2. Tracing the New Guinea Command Chain

Blamey’s own cable fixed the succession: “Urge that Herring be sent immediately by air as successor to Rowell. If Herring not approved, Mackay second choice” — the relief by which this wiki’s Edmund Herring entry reaches New Guinea Force. (Wikipedia — Sydney Rowell)

3. Philippine Liberation Framing

His six weeks in command were the defence of Port Moresby — the Track, Milne Bay, and Wau alike — the base from which, in this wiki’s Kokoda Track Campaign entry, New Guinea became the “stepping-stone to the reconquest of the Philippines.” (ADB — Rowell)

Strategies

  • Report facts, not colour, to the theater: Rowell “refused to give” MacArthur’s General Headquarters in Brisbane “a ‘ball to ball’ description of the action, sending only factual information at stated times.” (Wikipedia — Sydney Rowell)
  • Hold the supply gate: learning “that only about 10 per cent of the supplies and ammunition dropped by air was being recovered,” he “placed the 7th Division on the defensive until stocks for an offensive could be accumulated.” (ADB — Rowell)
  • Refuse a command that is not one: “Either I am fit to command the show or I am not.” (ADB — Rowell)
  • Appeal over the commander to the government: warning Forde that the affair might become “a first-class political row,” he carried his case to Menzies and the War Cabinet. (ADB — Rowell)

Security and Safety Measures

Historical Context

Rowell, fourth son of an English-born soldier and orchardist, entered Duntroon with its first cadets in 1911, and got from the war a few months at Gallipoli and twenty years of juniority; the peace gave him Camberley, the Imperial Defence College, and Blamey’s choice of him as the 6th Division’s chief of staff in October 1939. (Wikipedia — Sydney Rowell, ADB — Rowell) Greece split the two men for good: the withdrawal convinced Rowell that Blamey was “quite incompetent as a field commander in modern war,” and back in Palestine “he wrote to Sturdee that he would never again serve in the field under Blamey.” (ADB — Rowell)

The Kokoda crisis delivered him into exactly that service: given I Corps in 1942, he reached Port Moresby in August to find Kokoda lost and ran the defence by the rule of supply until Curtin, at MacArthur’s prompting, sent Blamey to take command. (Wikipedia — Sydney Rowell, ADB — Rowell) In three “brawls” he displayed his “personal animus” towards Blamey; on 28 September Blamey dismissed him, and MacArthur, finding his conduct “quite unpardonable,” never agreed to his holding a command again. (ADB — Rowell, Wikipedia — Sydney Rowell)

The postwar Army was his vindication. Chifley, hearing the story, answered: “I hate bloody injustice!” In 1946 Rowell became vice-chief with his rank restored, handled the politics of the 1949 coal strike while Berryman’s soldiers mined it, and from April 1950 presided as Chief of the General Staff over the Korean War expansion of the Regular Army until his retirement in December 1954. (Wikipedia — Sydney Rowell, ADB — Rowell)

Challenges and Controversies

Insubordination, or Principle?

Blamey reported him “most difficult and recalcitrant,” and “insubordinate and obstructive”; Rowell’s own case was that “Either I am fit to command the show or I am not,” having found Blamey “quite incompetent as a field commander in modern war.” (ADB — Rowell, Wikipedia — Kokoda Track campaign) Horner’s judgment, as the campaign article carries it, is that Rowell’s “only failure was an inability to work with Blamey” and that “Blamey was more culpable.” (Wikipedia — Kokoda Track campaign)

“Defeatist” — Kenney’s Word

“Failure to keep GHQ up to date,” the reference article observes, “could only lead to fears of the worst”: Kenney reported that Port Moresby would soon fall “unless something drastic was done,” and Rowell was “defeatist.” (Wikipedia — Sydney Rowell)

Related Topic

  • Kokoda Track campaign
  • New Guinea Force
  • I Corps (Australia)
  • Thomas Blamey
  • Edmund Herring
  • Arnold Potts
  • Arthur Allen
  • George Vasey
  • Douglas MacArthur
  • Vernon Sturdee
  • Royal Military College, Duntroon
  • Korean War
  • Chief of the General Staff (Australia)

References

  1. Sydney Rowell — Wikipedia
  2. Sir Sydney Fairbairn Rowell (1894–1975) — Australian Dictionary of Biography
  3. Kokoda Track campaign — Wikipedia
  4. Senior Australian Army officers in Korea, 1953 — Lieutenant General Sir Sydney Rowell, CGS — Australian War Memorial (photograph 044755)
  5. Sydney Rowell (Q7660119) — Wikidata
  6. Sydney Rowell — DBpedia (data endpoint)
  7. Class: Sydney Rowell — Product Ontology
  8. Rowell — Wiktionary

Twenty Twenty-Five

Designed with WordPress