Arthur Allen

Also known as: Arthur Samuel Allen — the full name of the reference record, and the redirect title of the encyclopedia article · "Tubby" — the nickname the troops and public used, "short, thickset and powerfully built" as he was ([ADB — Allen](https://adb.anu.edu.au/biography/allen-arthur-samuel-tubby-9337 "Arthur Samuel (Tubby) Allen (1894–1959) — Australian Dictionary of Biography"))

History

Definition

Arthur Allen — Major General Arthur Samuel Allen, born 10 March 1894 at Hurstville, Sydney, died 25 January 1959 at Concord, New South Wales — was an Australian Army officer and accountant who commanded the 16th Brigade at Bardia, Tobruk, and in Greece, and then the 7th Australian Division through the Syria campaign and the Kokoda Track counter-offensive of 1942, until he was relieved in the “crisis of command” that the Papua campaign’s pressures produced. (Wikipedia — Arthur Allen (general), ADB — Allen) A part-time soldier of the classic pattern — audit clerk, Militia cadet, commissioned 1913 — he went to the First World War as a reinforcement of the 13th Battalion and finished it as the battalion’s commanding officer, a substantive lieutenant colonel at twenty-four, with the DSO of Messines, the temporary command of the 48th Battalion at Monument Wood, and the French Croix de Guerre. (ADB — Allen) Between the wars an accountant in partnership and a Militia brigadier from 1938, he took the 16th Brigade to the Middle East in 1939, won his spurs in Libya and Greece, and assumed the 7th Division on 18 June 1941 in Syria — the division he brought home in 1942 to the Owen Stanleys, where his pursuit of the Japanese withdrawal over the range was judged “too slow” from Brisbane and Melbourne, and cost him the command. (ADB — Allen, Wikipedia — Kokoda Track campaign)

This wiki carries him inside its Papua cluster: the 7th Division that Allen led up the track in August–October 1942 was the formation George Vasey then commanded at Buna–Gona beside the U.S. 32nd Infantry Division — the “Red Arrow” division whose Philippine record this site documents. (Wikipedia — Battle of Buna–Gona) The ADB’s verdict stands as his register: the complaints against him “were based on ignorance of the conditions and were not justified.” (ADB — Allen)

Identities

Source Type Identity
Wikipedia Arthur Allen (general) — the canonical article; “Arthur Samuel Allen” redirects to it (both verified this session)
Wikidata Arthur Samuel Allen (Q4800228) — “Australian general” (verified this session via the search API) (Wikidata — Q4800228)
DBpedia Arthur_Allen_(general) — MilitaryPerson; Arthur_Samuel_Allen stands as a redirect resource to it (verified this session at the data endpoint) (DBpedia — Arthur Allen (general))
ProductOntology N/A
Wiktionary Allen — proper noun, “An English and Scottish surname transferred from the given name derived from the given name Alan” (headword verified this session; the general is not a headword) (Wiktionary — Allen)
Library of Congress Subject Headings (LCSH) Allen, Arthur Samuel, 1894–1959 — authorized heading, nr2005003409 (verified this session via the suggest API) (LCSH — Allen, Arthur Samuel)
MeSH N/A
NCBI Taxonomy N/A
AGROVOC N/A
Google Scholar Arthur Samuel Allen Tubby major general 1894 1959 Hurstville 13th Battalion 45th Battalion 48th Battalion Messines DSO Monument Wood Croix de Guerre accountant 14th Brigade 16th Brigade Bardia Tobruk Greece Piniós Gorge 7th Division Syria Damour Kokoda Track Eora Creek relief October 1942 Vasey Blamey MacArthur Northern Territory Force
ConceptNet N/A
OpenCyc N/A

Also Known As

  • Arthur Samuel Allen — the full name of the reference record, and the redirect title of the encyclopedia article
  • “Tubby” — the nickname the troops and public used, “short, thickset and powerfully built” as he was (ADB — Allen)

Examples and Analogies

  • The citizen-soldier’s whole arc in one life: audit clerk to battalion commander by twenty-four, accountant between the wars, divisional commander at forty-seven — the Militia-and-AIF pattern by which Australia’s part-time soldiers became its generals. (ADB — Allen)
  • The general who was told he was slow and was not: judged from headquarters miles from the jungle, his pursuit was blamed for caution when his problem was supply — “acutely aware of the logistical problems facing his force,” in the campaign record, with pressure applied “without being able to assure his supply.” (Wikipedia — Kokoda Track campaign)
  • The reply to MacArthur: told by MacArthur, after the relief, that the critical messages had been mere encouragement, Allen answered: “Well, that’s not the way to urge Australians.” (ADB — Allen)
  • Verified service data (each item to its carrier):
  • Life: born 10 March 1894, Hurstville, Sydney; died 25 January 1959, Concord, of hypertensive cerebrovascular disease; military funeral, cremated; survived by his wife Agnes (married 7 December 1921) and two sons (ADB — Allen, Wikipedia — Arthur Allen (general))
  • First World War: commissioned September 1913 in the Militia; AIF 24 June 1915; captain, 45th Battalion, March 1916; Pozières August 1916; DSO at Messines 7–11 June 1917; major July 1917; the 45th at Dernancourt April 1918; temporary lieutenant colonel, 48th Battalion, at Monument Wood May 1918; substantive lieutenant colonel and CO 13th Battalion from 20 November 1918; Croix de Guerre; AIF appointment ended 10 November 1919 (ADB — Allen)
  • Interwar: chartered accountant, partner in Truman Harrison & Co.; commanded the 13th, 41st, 18th, and 36th Battalions to 1933; colonel commanding 14th Brigade 1933; brigadier 1 May 1938 (ADB — Allen)
  • Second World War: 16th Brigade, 6th Division, October 1939; Bardia 3–5 January 1941 and Tobruk 21–22 January 1941 (CBE 1941, CB later that year); Greece from 18 March 1941 — the Piniós Gorge rearguard of 17 April, Kalamata 27 April (Greek Military Cross); GOC 7th Division 18 June 1941 in Syria; major general August 1941; Australia March 1942; Port Moresby 13 August 1942; relieved 28–29 October 1942; later appointments in Port Moresby and the Northern Territory (Northern Territory Force 1943–44); Reserve of Officers 30 April 1945 (ADB — Allen, Wikipedia — Arthur Allen (general))
  • Honours denied: Blamey recommended him for a KBE in October 1944; none followed — “a knighthood, which would have been automatic in World War I, did not eventuate” (ADB — Allen)

Usage Scenarios

1. Studying the Kokoda Crisis of Command

Allen is the third of the campaign’s three sackings — after Rowell and Potts — the sequence this wiki’s Kokoda Track Campaign and Thomas Blamey entries document as the “crisis of command” produced by MacArthur’s maneuvering and Blamey’s relays; the campaign article dates his replacement by Vasey to 28 October 1942, the battle article to the same day, and the biographical register to 29 October — “next day” after the Eora Creek breakthrough of the 28th. (Wikipedia — Kokoda Track campaign, Wikipedia — Battle of Buna–Gona, ADB — Allen)

2. Working the 7th Division’s 1942 Handover

His command spans the division’s Syria-to-Papua arc: Damour and Tripoli in 1941, the Kokoda pursuit in 1942, and the Buna–Gona inheritance Vasey fought under Herring’s New Guinea Force — the relief this wiki’s George Vasey entry carries (27 October in the standard account, 28 October by the campaign article’s). (Wikipedia — Kokoda Track campaign, Wikipedia — Battle of Buna–Gona)

3. Teaching Coalition Friction

The Allen case is the teaching example of allied pressure on national command: an Australian divisional commander rated “too slow” by an American theater commander who never saw the track, relieved by an Australian commander-in-chief transmitting that impatience. (Wikipedia — Kokoda Track campaign, ADB — Allen)

4. Philippine Liberation Framing

For the Philippine record Allen belongs to the road back’s opening leg: the division he led over the Owen Stanleys closed the Japanese threat to Port Moresby, the base from which the Southwest Pacific’s ladder — New Guinea, Morotai, Leyte — was later climbed. (Wikipedia — Kokoda Track campaign, Wikipedia — Battle of Buna–Gona)

5. The Northern Territory Command, 1943–44

After the relief he held home commands of lesser operational weight — Northern Territory Force among them, succeeded by Robert Nimmo. (Wikipedia — Arthur Allen (general))

Strategies

  • Hold ground to the pre-arranged time: at the Piniós Gorge on 17 April 1941 he “coolly held his ground until the pre-arranged time to fall back” — rearguard discipline as deliberate method, the skill he had learned commanding bombing fights at Messines. (ADB — Allen)
  • Organize the advance before fighting it: his “organization, enthusiasm and attention to detail” were credited at Bardia and Tobruk — the staff habit that made the 16th Brigade the 6th Division’s spearhead. (ADB — Allen)
  • Refuse to outrun supply: on the track he would not push brigades forward faster than the native carriers and airdrops could feed them — the caution his superiors read as slowness and his soldiers read as care. (Wikipedia — Kokoda Track campaign)
  • Keep the soldiers’ affection through defeat by headquarters: “blunt, honest, ‘choleric yet kindly'” and “completely without affectation or pomposity,” he kept the name the ranks gave him — the moral capital a relieved commander lives on. (ADB — Allen)

Security and Safety Measures

  • Supply as the division’s life: the Kokoda pursuit’s dependence on the carrier lines and the Myola drop zones — logistics, not aggression, setting the march rate — is the safety lesson his relief illustrates from the negative side. (Wikipedia — Kokoda Track campaign)
  • Pressure from above as a hazard: the “galling messages” of 11 October onward were a command-climate risk in themselves, wearing a divisional commander in the field for faults of terrain and transport. (ADB — Allen)
  • Fair process after the fact: the ADB’s exoneration, the MacArthur interview, and Blamey’s 1944 knighthood recommendation are the record’s own correction mechanisms — imperfect, but the ones the institution had. (ADB — Allen)
  • For researchers: keep the three relief dates apart and attributed — 27 October (the standard account this wiki’s Vasey entry carries), 28 October (the campaign and battle articles), 29 October (the biographical register’s “next day” after Eora Creek) — and keep the nicknames apart: the documented nickname is “Tubby”; no “Kingaroy” nickname appears in any record verified for this entry. (Wikipedia — Kokoda Track campaign, Wikipedia — Battle of Buna–Gona, ADB — Allen)

Historical Context

Allen came up through the citizen army’s every rank: the Hurstville cadets, the 39th Battalion Militia, a 1913 commission, and the AIF in June 1915. The Western Front made him — Pozières, the Somme winter, Messines where his bombing attacks cost the 45th Battalion sixteen officers and 552 soldiers and won him the DSO, Dernancourt, Monument Wood — and at twenty-four the 13th Battalion’s command. The interwar years ran the accountant’s ledger and the Militia’s brigade in parallel until October 1939 gave him the 16th Brigade of the new 2nd AIF. (ADB — Allen)

The Middle East campaigns were his proving ground: the Palestine advance party of February 1940, the breaches at Bardia and Tobruk in January 1941, the Greek rearguard at the Piniós Gorge, and on 18 June 1941 the 7th Division’s command in Syria against the Vichy French. Returned to Australia in March 1942, he reached Port Moresby on 13 August to take the offensive over the Owen Stanleys — the pursuit through Myola (10 October), Templeton’s Crossing (16–20 October), and Eora Creek that the campaign record documents under the supply troubles and the headquarters pressure that broke him: relieved at the end of October, succeeded by Vasey, the division passing into the Buna–Gona battles beside the Americans. (ADB — Allen, Wikipedia — Kokoda Track campaign, Wikipedia — Battle of Buna–Gona)

The war’s remainder was the home commands — Port Moresby appointments, Northern Territory Force 1943–44 — and the Reserve of Officers from 30 April 1945; Blamey’s October 1944 knighthood recommendation never took effect. Postwar he senior-partnered A. S. Allen & Co. in Sydney and died at Concord in January 1959; William Dargie’s portrait of him hangs in the Australian War Memorial. (Wikipedia — Arthur Allen (general), ADB — Allen)

Challenges and Controversies

The Relief: Three Dates and One Verdict

The register disagrees on the day — 27, 28, or 29 October 1942 — and agrees on the injustice: the campaign article’s 28 October, the battle article’s 28 October, the ADB’s “next day” 29 October after the Eora breakthrough, and the standard account’s 27 October carried in this wiki’s Vasey entry, against the ADB’s finding that the complaints “were based on ignorance of the conditions and were not justified.” (Wikipedia — Kokoda Track campaign, Wikipedia — Battle of Buna–Gona, ADB — Allen)

MacArthur, Blamey, and the Colonial Chain of Pressure

From 11 October 1942 the galling messages came from both the American theater commander and the Australian commander-in-chief; the campaign record blames “unreasonable and unrealistic perceptions of the terrain and conditions”; MacArthur’s later, disarming surprise at Allen’s distress — met with “that’s not the way to urge Australians” — is the episode’s epitome. (ADB — Allen, Wikipedia — Kokoda Track campaign)

The Knighthood That Never Came

Blamey’s KBE recommendation of October 1944 — the commander-in-chief’s own form of apology, as the record reads it — produced nothing: the general who commanded a division in three campaigns ended his career without the honour his peers wore. (ADB — Allen)

The Nickname Question

Popular retellings occasionally attach a “Kingaroy” nickname to Allen; no record verified for this entry carries it — Kingaroy, Queensland belongs to other wartime histories — and the only documented nickname is “Tubby,” earned from his build and kept by affection. The correction stands with the relief-date register as the entry’s fact-check. (ADB — Allen, Wikipedia — Arthur Allen (general))

Related Topic

References

  1. Arthur Allen (general) — Wikipedia
  2. Arthur Samuel (Tubby) Allen (1894–1959) — Australian Dictionary of Biography
  3. Kokoda Track campaign — Wikipedia
  4. Battle of Buna–Gona — Wikipedia
  5. Arthur Samuel Allen (Q4800228) — Wikidata
  6. Arthur Allen (general) — DBpedia (data endpoint)
  7. Allen — Wiktionary
  8. Allen, Arthur Samuel, 1894–1959 — Library of Congress Subject Headings (authority record)

Twenty Twenty-Five

Designed with WordPress