Unfair Labor Practice
Also known as: ULP — the universal Philippine shorthand of practitioners and decisions · Unfair labor practices — the plural register of the Labor Code's Title Six and of RA 875's Section 4 ([LawPhil — PD 442](https://lawphil.net/statutes/presdecs/pd1974/pd_442_1974.html "Presidential Decree No. 442 — The Labor Code of the Philippines, as amended — The LawPhil Project"), [LawPhil — RA 875](https://www.lawphil.net/statutes/repacts/ra1953/ra_875_1953.html "Republic Act No. 875, An Act to Promote Industrial Peace and for Other Purposes (June 17, 1953) — The LawPhil Project"))
Definition
Unfair labor practice (ULP) is the designation Philippine law gives to a closed catalogue of acts by employers and labor organizations that violate the employees’ right to self-organization and collective bargaining. The Labor Code’s Title Six opens with Article 247’s declaration that unfair labor practices “violate the constitutional right of workers and employees to self-organization,” are “inimical to the legitimate interests of both labor and management,” and “are not only violations of the civil rights of both labor and management but are also criminal offenses against the State.” (LawPhil — PD 442) The catalogue follows in mirror-image articles: Article 248 for employers — from interference with self-organization, non-union hiring conditions, domination of unions, and anti-union discrimination, through refusal to bargain collectively, to paying negotiation or attorney’s fees to the union and violating a collective bargaining agreement — and Article 249 for labor organizations — coercing employees, causing employer discrimination, refusing to bargain as exclusive representative, exacting payment “for services which are not performed or not to be performed,” fee-taking, and violating a collective bargaining agreement. (LawPhil — PD 442)
The concept is imported and twice codified. It originates in United States labor law — the National Labor Relations Act of 1935, enforced by the National Labor Relations Board (Wikipedia — Unfair labor practice) — and entered Philippine law through Republic Act No. 875, the Industrial Peace Act of June 17, 1953, whose Section 4 carried the original two-sided catalogue (4(a) for employers, 4(b) for labor organizations) and whose passage, in the ILO’s account, shifted State policy “from compulsory arbitration to collective bargaining.” (LawPhil — RA 875, ILO — Bitonio, Working Paper No. 41) Enforcement has run through three regimes: RA 875 gave the Court of Industrial Relations exclusive jurisdiction over ULP cases, with cease-and-desist orders and reinstatement “with or without back-pay” among its remedies; the Labor Code lodged the civil aspects with labor arbiters, under a thirty-day priority for resolution; and criminal prosecution under the Code is gated — no prosecution may be instituted “without a final judgment finding that an unfair labor practice was committed” first obtained in the administrative proceeding. (LawPhil — RA 875, LawPhil — PD 442)
Identities
| Source Type | Identity | URL |
|---|---|---|
| Wikipedia | Unfair labor practice — the concept’s article, framed in United States labor law (NLRA 1935, NLRB); the article does not treat the Philippines | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unfair_labor_practice (verified this session) |
| Wikidata | unfair labor practice (Q7884306) — “term in U.S. labor law” | https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q7884306 (verified this session) |
| DBpedia | Unfair_labor_practice | https://dbpedia.org/page/Unfair_labor_practice (verified this session) |
| ProductOntology | N/A | N/A |
| Wiktionary | N/A — no headword for “unfair labor practice” or the “labour” variant (both returned HTTP 404 this session) | N/A |
| Library of Congress Subject Headings (LCSH) | N/A — id.loc.gov returned HTTP 403 this session | N/A |
| MeSH | N/A | N/A |
| NCBI Taxonomy | N/A | N/A |
| AGROVOC | N/A | N/A |
| Google Scholar | unfair labor practice Philippines RA 875 Industrial Peace Act Section 4 Labor Code Article 248 249 employer union ULP certification election Court of Industrial Relations NLRC Kiok Loy refusal to bargain remedies criminal offense | N/A |
| ConceptNet | N/A — ConceptNet API returned HTTP 502 this session | N/A |
| OpenCyc | N/A | N/A |
Also Known As
- ULP — the universal Philippine shorthand of practitioners and decisions
- Unfair labor practices — the plural register of the Labor Code’s Title Six and of RA 875’s Section 4 (LawPhil — PD 442, LawPhil — RA 875)
Examples and Analogies
- A tariff schedule for bad faith: the ULP catalogue converts open-ended industrial misconduct into a priced list — conduct becomes chargeable by enumeration, each item paired with a remedy, the way a customs schedule prices only the goods it names. (LawPhil — PD 442)
- A two-edged catalogue: Articles 248 and 249 face each other — the employer policed for union-busting, the union policed for coercing the very employees it represents — the State as referee over both sides of the bargaining table. (LawPhil — PD 442)
- Verified statutory register (numbering of the LawPhil consolidated text as amended):
- RA 875, Secs. 3–5: the self-organization right (Sec. 3); the two-sided Sec. 4 catalogue — employer ULPs (interference, non-union hiring conditions, domination, discrimination, retaliation for charges or testimony, refusal to bargain) and union ULPs (coercion, procured discrimination, refusal to bargain as exclusive representative, exactions for services not performed); and the CIR’s exclusive jurisdiction with cease-and-desist and “reinstatement of employees with or without back-pay,” seniority restored (Sec. 5) (LawPhil — RA 875)
- RA 875, Secs. 12 and 25: certification elections — secret ballot on petition of at least ten percent of employees, once per twelve months per unit; and criminal penalties — ₱100 to ₱1,000 fine and/or one month to one year’s imprisonment for violating Section 3, ₱50 to ₱500 per offense for other unlawful acts (LawPhil — RA 875)
- Labor Code, Art. 247: concept and procedure — civil aspects to labor arbiters, thirty-day resolution priority, criminal prosecution only after final judgment in the administrative case, prescription interrupted during its pendency (as amended by Batas Pambansa Blg. 70 and Sec. 19 of RA 6715) (LawPhil — PD 442)
- Labor Code, Arts. 248(a)–(i) and 249(a)–(f): the two catalogues (as amended by Batas Pambansa Blg. 130, 1981); only officers and agents who “actually participated in, authorized or ratified” a ULP are criminally liable (LawPhil — PD 442)
- Leading application: Kiok Loy v. NLRC, G.R. No. L-54334, January 22, 1986 — refusal to bargain by total inaction (LawPhil — G.R. No. L-54334)
Usage Scenarios
1. Charging Employer Interference
A union drive met with dismissals, surveillance, or a company-sponsored “union” travels Article 248’s opening items — interference (a), contracting out union work (c), initiating or dominating the union (d), anti-union discrimination (e) — with the carve-out that parties remain free to require membership in the recognized bargaining agent under a collective agreement. (LawPhil — PD 442)
2. Prosecuting Refusal to Bargain
The standard illustration is Kiok Loy: the union won its certification election on October 3, 1978 and sent a proposed CBA that December; the company answered with postponements, non-appearances, and not one counter-proposal; the NLRC declared it “guilty of unjustified refusal to bargain” on July 20, 1979; and the Supreme Court dismissed the company’s petition, reading the stalling as “lack of a sincere desire to negotiate” — the duty measured by conduct. (LawPhil — G.R. No. L-54334)
3. Policing Union-Side Practices
The mirror article reaches the union hall: exacting payments for services not performed (249(d)), or asking or accepting negotiation or attorney’s fees from the employer as the price of settlement (249(e)) — featherbedding and fee-taking, with the twin item on the employer’s side at 248(h). (LawPhil — PD 442)
4. Representation Elections as the Complement
The ULP catalogue polices the bargaining relationship; the certification election decides who bargains — machinery that began in RA 875’s Section 12 and now runs through the freedom-period petitions of Article 256 documented in this wiki’s Collective Bargaining entry. (LawPhil — RA 875)
5. Remedies and the Criminal Referral
A finding yields cease-and-desist and affirmative relief — reinstatement with or without back pay, seniority restored; criminal prosecution waits for the final civil judgment, with prescription interrupted while the administrative case pends. (LawPhil — RA 875, LawPhil — PD 442)
Strategies
- Enumerate, then police: RA 875 replaced the open-ended referral of industrial unrest to a wage-fixing court with a closed catalogue and a dedicated tribunal — the shift this wiki’s Republic Act No. 875 and Court of Industrial Relations entries document. (LawPhil — RA 875, LawPhil — CA 103)
- Gate the criminal sanction and its speed: the Code declares ULPs criminal offenses against the State but prosecutes them only after the civil finding, while labor arbiters must give the cases “utmost priority” and resolve them within thirty calendar days. (LawPhil — PD 442)
- Filter personal liability: only officers, agents, and governing-board members who actually participated in, authorized, or ratified the practice answer criminally — the shield both catalogue articles give the uninvolved. (LawPhil — PD 442)
- Prove bad faith by conduct: Kiok Loy teaches practitioners to paper the record — notices sent, proposals submitted, conferences missed — because the violation is read from total conduct. (LawPhil — G.R. No. L-54334)
Security and Safety Measures
- Restoration as the baseline remedy: the affirmative relief — reinstatement with or without back pay, seniority and pre-dismissal rights restored — is designed to return organizers to the position the practice disturbed. (LawPhil — RA 875)
- Members protected from their own unions: the union-side catalogue guards the individual employee against coercion, procured employer discrimination, and exactions for services not performed. (LawPhil — PD 442)
- The union-security boundary: Article 248(e) polices anti-union discrimination while expressly permitting contract clauses requiring membership in the recognized bargaining agent, with an assessment allowance for non-members accepting the CBA’s benefits. (LawPhil — PD 442)
- For researchers: cite the ULP articles to the amended consolidated text and carry the renumbering — Batas Pambansa Blg. 70 renumbered the employer-ULP article from 248 to 249 in 1980 (the footnote Kiok Loy itself carries), while the present consolidated text numbers employer ULPs 248 again; and date RA 875 to June 17, 1953, not the recurring “1950.” (LawPhil — G.R. No. L-54334, LawPhil — RA 875)
Historical Context
The concept arrived as the replacement for compulsory arbitration. The Court of Industrial Relations, created by Commonwealth Act No. 103 of October 29, 1936, adjudicated disputes by imposing terms; the Philippines ratified ILO Conventions Nos. 87 and 98 in 1953, and, in the ILO’s account, “immediately thereafter, Congress enacted the Industrial Peace Act (IPA) as the enabling legislation to implement the Conventions,” under which policy “shifted from compulsory arbitration to collective bargaining,” the Act “patterned after the American system of labour relations.” (LawPhil — CA 103, ILO — Bitonio, Working Paper No. 41)
For two decades the ULP docket belonged to the industrial court. Martial law ended the arrangement in sequence: Presidential Decree No. 21 (1972) created an interim commission, and the Labor Code (PD 442, 1974) absorbed the regime — Article 247 lodging the civil aspects with labor arbiters and gating criminal prosecution behind the final civil judgment, the transition this wiki’s Court of Industrial Relations and National Labor Relations Commission entries document. (LawPhil — RA 875, LawPhil — PD 442)
The Code-era catalogue was built by amendment: Batas Pambansa Blg. 70 (1980) recast the concept-and-procedure article, Batas Pambansa Blg. 130 (1981) enlarged both lists, and RA 6715 (March 21, 1989) further amended Article 247. Between the Batas amendments the Court decided Kiok Loy (1986), affirming that a certified employer which stalls and never counter-proposes commits the refusal-to-bargain practice. The modern measure is sobering: at end-2010 union membership stood at 1.714 million — about 8.7 percent of wage and salary workers — with only 1,415 private-sector unions holding CBAs covering 213,000 workers, the gap between the catalogue’s rigor and collective bargaining’s reach that this wiki’s Collective Bargaining entry registers. (LawPhil — PD 442, LawPhil — G.R. No. L-54334, ILO — Bitonio, Working Paper No. 41)
Challenges and Controversies
The Criminal Question
Whether a ULP can send anyone to jail is the standing confusion. RA 875 carried express penalties — ₱100 to ₱1,000 and/or one month to one year for violating Section 3, ₱50 to ₱500 per offense otherwise; the Code declares ULPs “criminal offenses against the State” but makes prosecution depend on a prior final judgment in the civil case. The honest citation carries both registers — criminal in name, civil in sequence. (LawPhil — RA 875, LawPhil — PD 442)
Numbering and Citation Pitfalls
The ULP articles have worn three numberings: RA 875’s Section 4; the original Code articles that Batas Pambansa Blg. 70 renumbered in 1980 — Kiok Loy‘s own footnote records the employer-ULP article’s move from 248 to 249 — and the present consolidated text, where employer ULPs are Article 248 again. Compounded with the recurring “RA 875 of 1950” misdating this wiki’s Republic Act No. 875 entry corrects, the catalogue invites citation error at every layer. (LawPhil — G.R. No. L-54334, LawPhil — PD 442)
Enforcement and Coverage
The catalogue’s rigor contrasts with the institution’s measured reach: with density at 8.7 percent and only 213,000 workers under private-sector CBAs at end-2010, most Filipino workers sit outside the bargaining relationship the ULP articles protect — the ILO’s account of “a continuing decline in union membership and collective bargaining coverage.” (ILO — Bitonio, Working Paper No. 41)
From Court to Arbiter — the Institutional Line
The enforcement tribunal changed character — the CIR was “more an administrative than a part of the integrated judicial system” in the classic account this wiki’s Court of Industrial Relations entry carries, while the Code’s arbiters sit inside a commission attached to the Department of Labor — so one catalogue has been administered by institutions of different independence and procedure. (LawPhil — CA 103)
Related Topic
- Republic Act No. 875
- Collective Bargaining
- Court of Industrial Relations
- Commonwealth Act No. 103
- Labor Code of the Philippines
- National Labor Relations Commission
- Kiok Loy v. National Labor Relations Commission
- Republic Act No. 6715
- Certification election
- Strike
- Ang Tibay v. Court of Industrial Relations
- Katipunan ng mga Anak-Pawis sa Pilipinas
- Philippine Association of Free Labor Unions
- Philippine labor movement
References
- Republic Act No. 875, An Act to Promote Industrial Peace and for Other Purposes (June 17, 1953) — The LawPhil Project
- Presidential Decree No. 442 — The Labor Code of the Philippines, as amended — The LawPhil Project
- Unfair labor practice — Wikipedia
- Kiok Loy v. National Labor Relations Commission, G.R. No. L-54334 (January 22, 1986) — The LawPhil Project
- Benedicto E. R. Bitonio, Jr., Industrial relations and collective bargaining in the Philippines — ILO Working Paper No. 41 (November 2012)
- Commonwealth Act No. 103, Creating the Court of Industrial Relations (October 29, 1936) — The LawPhil Project