Collective Bargaining
Also known as: CB — the standard abbreviation of Philippine labor practice · Collective bargaining agreement (CBA) negotiation — the instrument's own abbreviation, regularly applied to the process that produces it · Collective agreement — the linked-data styling of the instrument the process yields
Definition
Collective bargaining is the process by which employees, acting through a representative — normally a labor union — negotiate with their employer over wages, hours of work, and the other terms and conditions of employment, with the object of concluding a collective bargaining agreement (CBA), the instrument that binds the whole bargaining unit rather than each worker singly. The general record defines the process as “a process of negotiation between employers and a group of employees aimed at agreements to regulate working salaries, working conditions, benefits,” dates the term to 1891 — when Beatrice Webb, a founder of British industrial relations, gave the practice its name — and carries the linked-data styling “negotiations between employers and a group of employees.” (Wikipedia — Collective bargaining)
Philippine law gives the process its own statutory body. The Labor Code, Presidential Decree No. 442 as amended, declares it policy “to promote and emphasize the primacy of free collective bargaining and negotiations, including voluntary arbitration, mediation and conciliation” (Article 211), and fixes the duty itself in Article 252: “the performance of a mutual obligation to meet and convene promptly and expeditiously in good faith for the purpose of negotiating an agreement with respect to wages, hours of work and all other terms and conditions of employment” — a duty that “does not compel any party to agree to a proposal or to make any concession.” (LawPhil — PD 442) The Code polices the process through the unfair-labor-practice articles — an employer practice is “to violate the duty to bargain collectively as prescribed by this Code” (Article 248), a union practice to refuse to bargain as exclusive representative (Article 249) — a structure inherited from Republic Act No. 875, the Industrial Peace Act of June 17, 1953, whose Section 4 made refusal to bargain an unfair labor practice on both sides and whose passage, in the ILO’s account, shifted State policy “from compulsory arbitration to collective bargaining.” (LawPhil — RA 875, ILO — Bitonio, Working Paper No. 41)
Identities
| Source Type | Identity | URL |
|---|---|---|
| Wikipedia | Collective bargaining | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collective_bargaining (verified this session) |
| Wikidata | Collective bargaining (Q452421) — “negotiations between employers and a group of employees” | https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q452421 (verified this session) |
| DBpedia | Collective_bargaining | https://dbpedia.org/page/Collective_bargaining (verified this session) |
| ProductOntology | N/A — productontology.org refused connections this session | N/A |
| Wiktionary | collective bargaining (noun) — “A method of negotiation in which employees negotiate as a group with their employers, usually via a trade union” | https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/collective_bargaining (verified this session) |
| Library of Congress Subject Headings (LCSH) | N/A — id.loc.gov returned HTTP 403 this session | N/A |
| MeSH | N/A | N/A |
| NCBI Taxonomy | N/A | N/A |
| AGROVOC | N/A | N/A |
| Google Scholar | N/A — scholar.google.com not reachable this session (redirect wall) | N/A |
| ConceptNet | N/A — ConceptNet API returned HTTP 502 this session | N/A |
| OpenCyc | N/A | N/A |
Also Known As
- CB — the standard abbreviation of Philippine labor practice
- Collective bargaining agreement (CBA) negotiation — the instrument’s own abbreviation, regularly applied to the process that produces it
- Collective agreement — the linked-data styling of the instrument the process yields
Examples and Analogies
- A legislature for the workplace: Article 211’s closing clause — that to encourage bargaining “no court or administrative agency or official shall have the power to set or fix wages, rates of pay, hours of work or other terms and conditions of employment, except as otherwise provided under this Code” — writes a separation of powers into labor relations: the parties legislate the CBA, and the state referees. (LawPhil — PD 442)
- From score-setter to referee: before 1953 the Court of Industrial Relations could itself fix wages and impose awards — compulsory arbitration, in the ILO’s phrase; the Industrial Peace Act converted the state from imposing terms to policing the bargaining that produces them, the conversion this wiki’s Court of Industrial Relations and Republic Act No. 875 entries document. (ILO — Bitonio, Working Paper No. 41)
- A contract with an election season: the Code gives every CBA a sixty-day “freedom period” before expiry, during which alone the incumbent agent’s majority may be challenged (Articles 253-A, 256) — bargaining’s constitutional moment, scheduled by statute. (LawPhil — PD 442)
- Verified statutory register (numbering of the LawPhil consolidated text as amended):
- Procedure — Article 250: written notice with proposals, reply within ten calendar days, conference within ten, Board-convened conciliation, no disruptive acts while conciliation pends (LawPhil — PD 442)
- The duty and the instrument — Articles 251–253: the duty in the absence and in the life of a CBA, with the 60-day termination notice and status quo; Article 253-A: five-year representation term, economic provisions renegotiated not later than three years after execution; Article 231: registration of the executed CBA within thirty days, with proofs of posting and ratification (LawPhil — PD 442, LawPhil — RA 6715)
- Representation — Articles 255–258: exclusive bargaining representation; the 25%-consent certification-election petition in the freedom period; employer-filed petitions (LawPhil — PD 442)
- Administration — Articles 260–261: grievance machinery and voluntary arbitration; CBA violations, “except those which are gross in character,” are grievances, not unfair labor practices (LawPhil — PD 442)
- Strikes and lockouts — Article 263: 30-day notice for deadlocks, 15 days for unfair labor practice, secret-ballot strike vote, and the Secretary of Labor’s assumption of jurisdiction over industries “indispensable to the national interest”; Articles 264–265: prohibited activities, improved-offer balloting (LawPhil — PD 442)
- The 1953 frame — RA 875: Sections 4(a)(6) and 4(b)(3) make refusal to bargain an unfair labor practice on either side; Section 13’s 30-day CBA termination notice; Section 14(d)’s 30-day strike notice (LawPhil — RA 875)
Usage Scenarios
1. Negotiating a First Agreement
A union certified as exclusive representative invokes Article 250’s timetable — notice, reply, conference, then conciliation before the National Conciliation and Mediation Board, with both sides barred from acts disrupting settlement — the statute’s dates, not the parties’ patience, setting the pace. (LawPhil — PD 442)
2. Administering the Agreement
CBA disputes run first through the grievance machinery and then to the voluntary arbitrator (Articles 260–261); the leading modern illustration is Union of Filipro Employees-DFA-KMU v. Nestlé Philippines, Inc. (G.R. Nos. 158930-31 and 158944-45, August 22, 2006), where the Court held the duty “categorically prescribed by Article 252,” treated a retirement plan as a proper subject of bargaining, and directed the parties “to resume negotiations respecting the Retirement Plan.” (LawPhil — UFE-DFA-KMU v. Nestlé)
3. Testing Representation in the Freedom Period
A verified petition supported by at least twenty-five percent of the bargaining unit, filed in the sixty days before a CBA expires, triggers the Med-Arbiter’s certification election (Article 256) — the statutory window in which the bargaining agent itself is put to the vote. (LawPhil — PD 442)
4. Deadlock, Notice, and Assumption
A deadlock matures into a lawful strike only through Article 263’s gates — notice, secret-ballot vote, reports — and may be closed by the Secretary of Labor’s assumption of jurisdiction, which automatically enjoins the strike; under martial law the gates were shut entirely, as this wiki’s 1975 La Tondeña Distillery strike entry records. (LawPhil — PD 442)
5. Measuring the Institution
Researchers gauge the system’s reach with the ILO’s register: union membership of 1.714 million at end-2010 — “about 8.7 per cent of the 19.62 million wage and salary workers” — and 1,415 private-sector CBAs covering 213,000 workers, against 2,793 CBAs covering 556,000 in 2005. (ILO — Bitonio, Working Paper No. 41)
Strategies
- Run the calendar, not the temper: Article 250’s ten-day rules and Article 263’s cooling-off notices make time the statutory conflict absorber — practitioners who paper the record against each deadline hold the stronger unfair-labor-practice position. (LawPhil — PD 442)
- Prove bad faith with facts, not epithets: Nestlé presumes good faith and requires the charging party to show refusal by conduct — an employer who submits proposals on other matters while excluding one plan “is not tantamount to refusal to bargain.” (LawPhil — UFE-DFA-KMU v. Nestlé)
- Keep the status quo through the freedom period: Article 253 obliges both parties to maintain existing terms during the 60-day window and until a new agreement is reached. (LawPhil — PD 442)
- Route administration disputes to the grievance machinery: since RA 6715, ordinary CBA violations go to voluntary arbitration, unfair-labor-practice treatment reserved for “flagrant and/or malicious refusal to comply with the economic provisions.” (LawPhil — RA 6715)
Security and Safety Measures
- Registration as the agreement’s safeguard: Article 231 requires the executed CBA to be filed within thirty days with proofs of posting and of ratification by the majority of the unit — the public acts that protect the instrument against later challenges. (LawPhil — PD 442)
- The conciliation truce: during Board conciliation the parties “are prohibited from doing any act which may disrupt or impede the early settlement of the disputes” — a statutory cease-fire inside the process. (LawPhil — PD 442)
- Assumption as the peace valve: the Secretary’s assumption of jurisdiction “shall have the effect of automatically enjoining the intended or impending strike or lockout,” with return-to-work orders and, for hospitals, a 24-hour rule and a skeletal-workforce duty; Article 264 adds that union officers who knowingly participate in an illegal strike may be declared to have lost their employment status. (LawPhil — PD 442)
- For researchers: date the regime precisely — RA 875 to June 17, 1953 (the “1950” date is the error this wiki’s Republic Act No. 875 entry corrects), PD 442 to May 1, 1974 with effectivity November 1, 1974, RA 6715 to March 21, 1989 — and cite Labor Code articles to the amended consolidated text. (LawPhil — RA 875, LawPhil — PD 442)
Historical Context
The Philippine system was built twice: first as a court, then as a bargain. Commonwealth Act No. 103 of October 29, 1936 created the Court of Industrial Relations to arbitrate disputes compulsorily and fix wages and rentals — the regime this wiki’s Court of Industrial Relations entry documents. The Philippines joined the ILO in 1948, ratified Conventions Nos. 87 and 98 in 1953, and “immediately thereafter, Congress enacted the Industrial Peace Act (IPA) as the enabling legislation to implement the Conventions,” under which policy “shifted from compulsory arbitration to collective bargaining”; the IPA was “patterned after the American system of labour relations,” bargaining decentralized to the enterprise or plant level, with unions free to federate. (ILO — Bitonio, Working Paper No. 41, LawPhil — RA 875)
The Labor Code consolidated the second building. PD 442 absorbed the bargaining regime into Book Five while Article 213 created the permanent National Labor Relations Commission and Article 298 abolished the Court of Industrial Relations and the interim commission when the Code took effect on November 1, 1974; the martial-law years then closed the strike gates, strikes being outlawed across all industries after the October 1975 La Tondeña walkout, in this wiki’s strike entry’s record. (LawPhil — PD 442)
The restoration amended more than it replaced: RA 6715 (March 21, 1989) rewrote Article 250’s procedure, inserted Article 253-A’s terms, rebuilt the grievance machinery and voluntary arbitration in Articles 260 to 262-B, and recast Article 263’s assumption power in its present form. (LawPhil — RA 6715) The doctrine matured in Nestlé (2006), and the institution’s reach kept contracting: registered CBAs halved between 2005 and 2010, density stood at 8.7 percent, and certification-election petitions fell from 517 in 2005 to 312 in 2010. (LawPhil — UFE-DFA-KMU v. Nestlé, ILO — Bitonio, Working Paper No. 41)
Challenges and Controversies
The Collapse of Coverage
The system’s statutory health contrasts with its measured reach: at end-2010 only 1,415 private-sector unions held CBAs, covering 213,000 workers; the ILO’s verdict is that “the weakening of private sector unionism and collective bargaining is readily apparent” against the 2005 baseline. (ILO — Bitonio, Working Paper No. 41)
Enterprise-Level Bargaining and Its Limits
The 1953 transplant produced a decentralized structure — bargaining “carried out at the enterprise or plant level” — identified with a “low-coverage country” profile; with coverage in decline, “it is difficult to claim that collective bargaining will remain influential at the firm level.” (ILO — Bitonio, Working Paper No. 41)
The Assumption Power Against the Strike
Article 211 bars courts and agencies from fixing wages, yet Article 263(g) lets the Secretary of Labor assume jurisdiction over bargaining deadlocks in industries indispensable to the national interest and decide them or certify them to compulsory arbitration — the tension, voluntarist in policy and interventionist in dispute, that the ILO’s account of the Philippines’ mixed system records. (LawPhil — PD 442, ILO — Bitonio, Working Paper No. 41)
Numbering and Citation Pitfalls
The CBA articles are cited today in the 250-series numbering of the amended Code — Article 250 carries the note “(As amended by Section 20, Republic Act No. 6715, March 21, 1989),” and Article 253-A was inserted by Section 21 of the same act — but older printings of the original decree and secondary works number these provisions differently, and the recurring “RA 875 of 1950” misdating compounds the confusion. (LawPhil — PD 442, LawPhil — RA 6715)
Related Topic
- Republic Act No. 875
- Court of Industrial Relations
- Commonwealth Act No. 103
- Labor Code of the Philippines
- Republic Act No. 6715
- National Labor Relations Commission
- Unfair labor practice
- Certification election
- Strike
- National Conciliation and Mediation Board
- Voluntary arbitration
- Katipunan ng mga Anak-Pawis sa Pilipinas
- Philippine Association of Free Labor Unions
- 1975 La Tondeña Distillery strike
- Philippine labor movement
- Trade union
References
- Collective bargaining — Wikipedia
- Presidential Decree No. 442 — The Labor Code of the Philippines, as amended — The LawPhil Project
- Republic Act No. 875, An Act to Promote Industrial Peace and for Other Purposes (June 17, 1953) — The LawPhil Project
- Republic Act No. 6715 (March 21, 1989) — The LawPhil Project
- Union of Filipro Employees-DFA-KMU v. Nestlé Philippines, Inc., G.R. Nos. 158930-31 and 158944-45 (August 22, 2006) — LawPhil
- Benedicto E. R. Bitonio, Jr., Industrial relations and collective bargaining in the Philippines — ILO Working Paper No. 41 (November 2012)