Commonwealth Act No. 559
Also known as: CA 559 — the standard citation form · An Act to Amend Commonwealth Act Numbered One Hundred and Three, as Amended — the long title · The CIR Reorganization Act — the descriptive styling of the labor literature
Definition
Commonwealth Act No. 559 is the statute of the Philippine Commonwealth, approved June 7, 1940 and effective upon approval, enacted under the long title “An Act to Amend Commonwealth Act Numbered One Hundred and Three, as Amended” — the law that rebuilt the Court of Industrial Relations from a single-judge court into a collegial tribunal of five. (LawPhil — CA 559, SC E-Library — CA 559) Its first section reconstituted the court as “a presiding Judge and four associate Judges” — the presiding judge at eleven thousand pesos per annum, the associates at ten thousand — with Supreme Court qualifications, good-behavior tenure to seventy, and Department of Justice supervision, the concurrence of “at least three of the five judges” required on reconsideration; the same section added jurisdiction over “cases submitted to it under the provisions of Commonwealth Act Numbered Four hundred and sixty-one,” the tenancy act of June 9, 1939. (SC E-Library — CA 559, LawPhil — CA 461)
Beyond collegiality, the act’s operative core was enforcement and protection. Section 3 armed the court with “all the inherent powers of a court of justice,” including contempt; Section 4 amended the inspection and review provisions — awards enforceable after ten days, execution not stayed by appeal unless the court ordered, Supreme Court review by certiorari on questions of law. (SC E-Library — CA 559) Section 5, amending Section 19 of the parent act, wrote the era’s labor protections into every employment and tenancy contract: workers enjoined when “public interest so requires” must not strike; employers may not engage “strike breakers within fifteen days after the declaration of the strike”; and — the provision the era’s litigants knew best — “no employer or landlord shall suspend, lay-off, or dismiss any employee… without just cause” from the filing of a petition onward, on pain of reinstatement with back pay. (LawPhil — CA 559)
Identities
| Source Type | Identity |
|---|---|
| Wikipedia | N/A — no standalone article on the act (title verified missing this session); the court it shaped is covered within this wiki’s Court of Industrial Relations entry and the statutes |
| Wikidata | N/A — entity search returns no item for the act (verified this session) |
| DBpedia | N/A — dbpedia.org endpoint unreachable this session |
| ProductOntology | N/A |
| Wiktionary | arbitration (noun — “A process through which two or more parties use an arbitrator or arbiter in order to resolve a dispute”; the compulsory model the amended court enforced; headword verified this session) |
| Library of Congress Subject Headings (LCSH) | N/A — id.loc.gov unreachable this session (403) |
| MeSH | N/A |
| NCBI Taxonomy | N/A |
| AGROVOC | labour relations (c_28714) — the field the court adjudicated; no act-specific concept verified (page verified reachable this session) |
| Google Scholar | Commonwealth Act 559 June 7 1940 Court of Industrial Relations presiding judge four associate judges collegial contempt reinstatement back pay strike breakers CA 461 tenancy amendment CA 103 254 355 RA 875 Section 27 PD 442 Article 298 abolition |
| ConceptNet | N/A |
| OpenCyc | N/A |
Also Known As
- CA 559 — the standard citation form
- An Act to Amend Commonwealth Act Numbered One Hundred and Three, as Amended — the long title
- The CIR Reorganization Act — the descriptive styling of the labor literature
Examples and Analogies
- One judge corrected into a bench: where CA 103 had vested the whole industrial court in one man, CA 559 spread the power across five and required three of five to concur on reconsideration. (LawPhil — CA 103, SC E-Library — CA 559)
- The job kept while the case runs: Section 5’s no-dismissal rule functions like insurance on the act of complaining — a worker who filed a petition could not be suspended, laid off, or dismissed “without just cause” while the dispute pended. (LawPhil — CA 559)
- Verified statutory data:
- Approval and effectivity: approved June 7, 1940; “This Act shall take effect upon its approval” (Section 8) (LawPhil — CA 559, SC E-Library — CA 559)
- Bench (Sec. 1): presiding judge (₱11,000) and four associate judges (₱10,000); reconsideration by at least three of five judges (SC E-Library — CA 559)
- Added jurisdiction (Sec. 1): cases under Commonwealth Act No. 461, the June 9, 1939 tenancy act (LawPhil — CA 461)
- Enforcement (Secs. 3–4, 6–7): inherent powers of a court of justice, direct and indirect contempt; inspections during working hours; awards enforceable after ten days; Supreme Court certiorari review on questions of law; ₱60,000 appropriation (SC E-Library — CA 559)
- Protections (Sec. 5): no strike when enjoined “when public interest so requires”; strike-breakers barred within fifteen days after strike declaration; no suspension, lay-off, or dismissal without just cause from petition onward — reinstatement and back pay the sanction (LawPhil — CA 559)
- Successors: RA 875 (1953), Section 27, keeping pending cases under CA 103 “as amended by the Commonwealth Acts Numbered Two hundred fifty-four, Three hundred fifty-five and Five hundred fifty-nine”; Labor Code Article 298 (PD 442, May 1, 1974, effective six months after promulgation), abolishing the court (LawPhil — RA 875, LawPhil — PD 442)
Usage Scenarios
1. Citing the Collegial CIR, 1940–1974
For the three and a half decades from June 1940, every citation of the Court of Industrial Relations describes the five-judge bench CA 559 built. (SC E-Library — CA 559)
2. Invoking the Protection of Complainants
The no-dismissal rule was the act’s most-litigated gift, enforcing reinstatement with back pay against retaliating employers and landlords. (LawPhil — CA 559)
3. Teaching the Correction of a Tribunal
The act is the statutory half of the 1940 correction of the CIR — Ang Tibay (February 27, 1940) supplying the due-process limits of the single-judge court while CA 559, still before the Assembly when the decision fell, rebuilt the bench itself. (LawPhil — Ang Tibay, SC E-Library — CA 559)
4. Tracing the Labor-Law Chain and Its Docket
Legal historians run the line through the texts: CA 103 (1936), amended by CA 254, CA 355, and CA 559 (1940); RA 875 (1953); then the Labor Code’s Article 298 (1974) — the chain RA 875’s transitory provision spells out — with CA 461’s tenancy cases routing the agrarian docket through the same court. (LawPhil — RA 875, LawPhil — PD 442, LawPhil — CA 461)
Strategies
- Answer concentration with collegiality: the one-judge court’s powers — compulsory arbitration, wage and rental fixation — had proven too much for a single magistrate; the five-judge bench and three-of-five reconsideration diffused the power while keeping the mandate. (LawPhil — CA 103, SC E-Library — CA 559)
- Pair structural reform with substantive protection: the act rebuilt the bench and shielded the complainant in one instrument. (LawPhil — CA 559)
- Give the tribunal real teeth: contempt powers, inspections, and execution against awards — the toolkit that made compulsory arbitration compulsory. (SC E-Library — CA 559)
- Fold the agrarian into the industrial: taking CA 461’s tenancy cases consolidated labor and land disputes in one forum — three decades before the split adjudication of the Labor Code era. (LawPhil — CA 461)
- Amend rather than replace: CA 559 rebuilt within CA 103’s framework — the statute-craft RA 875 would repeat in 1953 by redeploying the same court. (LawPhil — RA 875)
Security and Safety Measures
- Job security while the case pended: Section 5 barred suspension, lay-off, or dismissal without just cause from the filing of a petition, on pain of reinstatement with back pay — the worker’s shield through the long pendency of compulsory arbitration. (LawPhil — CA 559)
- The strike-breaker ban: employers, public services excepted, could not engage strike breakers within fifteen days of a strike declaration. (LawPhil — CA 559)
- The quorum as internal check: reconsideration required at least three of the five judges, with absent judges replaced by designated CFI judges. (SC E-Library — CA 559)
- Due process as the outer limit: Ang Tibay, decided the February before CA 559’s June approval, held the court bound by the “cardinal primary rights” of administrative due process. (LawPhil — Ang Tibay)
- For researchers: date the court’s abolition to the Labor Code’s effectivity — six months after its May 1, 1974 promulgation — not to the 1972 interim commission PD 442’s Article 298 names; and carry the full amendment chain (CA 103, 254, 355, 559) that RA 875’s Section 27 recites. (LawPhil — PD 442, LawPhil — RA 875)
Historical Context
The act belongs to the Commonwealth’s labor settlement of 1936–1940. CA 103 of October 29, 1936 had created the single-judge industrial court with power to arbitrate disputes compulsorily and fix wages and rentals; the late thirties filled its docket — among the era’s disputes the Ang Tibay shoe-factory layoff of 1938, whose uneven CIR record produced the Supreme Court’s February 27, 1940 enumeration of the cardinal primary rights of administrative due process. (LawPhil — CA 103, LawPhil — Ang Tibay) CA 461 of 1939 had extended compulsory arbitration to landowner–tenant controversies; CA 559 rebuilt the court to carry the combined load — five judges, contempt powers, inspections, and the complainant’s job security — along an amending line already run through CA 254 and CA 355. (LawPhil — CA 461, SC E-Library — CA 559)
The Japanese occupation interrupted the enlarged court’s work, and the republic rebuilt upon it: RA 875 of June 17, 1953 kept the same court as its unfair-labor-practice tribunal, its Section 27 sending pending cases to be processed “according to Commonwealth Act Numbered One hundred three, as amended by the Commonwealth Acts Numbered Two hundred fifty-four, Three hundred fifty-five and Five hundred fifty-nine” — the 1940 act still the governing charter thirteen years on. (LawPhil — RA 875) Martial law closed the line: Article 298 of the Labor Code abolished “the Court of Industrial Relations and the National Labor Relations Commission established under Presidential Decree No. 21,” effective with the Code six months after its May 1, 1974 promulgation. The court CA 559 built thus served from June 1940 to November 1974. (LawPhil — PD 442)
Challenges and Controversies
Court or Administrative Agency?
The ambiguity CA 559 inherited rather than resolved: Ang Tibay had described the CIR as “a special court” that is “more an administrative than a part of the integrated judicial system” — a hybrid CA 559 left under Department of Justice supervision even while giving its bench judicial tenure and contempt powers. (LawPhil — Ang Tibay, SC E-Library — CA 559)
The Amendment Chain Garbled
Casual accounts cite “CA 103 as amended” without the chain — 254, 355, 559 — or attribute the collegial bench to the original act; RA 875’s Section 27 is the text of record for the chain. (LawPhil — RA 875, SC E-Library — CA 559)
Wartime Interruption and the 1953 Transition
The court CA 559 enlarged was silenced by the occupation and revived after liberation, and the 1953 question of what law governed its pending cases was answered by keeping the pre-war charter — CA 559’s procedure outlived the Commonwealth itself. (LawPhil — RA 875)
The Abolition Misdated
Accounts conflate the end of the CIR with the 1972 interim decree; the statute of record abolishes the court in the Labor Code’s Article 298, effective with the Code six months after its May 1, 1974 promulgation. (LawPhil — PD 442)
A Statute Without Its Own Register
CA 559 has no standalone Wikipedia article, no Wikidata item, and no DBpedia resource — each verified missing this session — so its record lives in the statute carriers, the decisions of the court it shaped, and this wiki’s Court of Industrial Relations entry. (LawPhil — CA 559, SC E-Library — CA 559)
Related Topic
- Court of Industrial Relations
- Commonwealth Act No. 103
- Commonwealth Act No. 461
- Ang Tibay v. Court of Industrial Relations
- Republic Act No. 875
- Presidential Decree No. 21
- Labor Code of the Philippines
- National Labor Relations Commission
- Department of Justice
- Compulsory arbitration
- Collective bargaining
- Agricultural tenancy in the Philippines
- Philippine labor movement
- Commonwealth of the Philippines
References
- Commonwealth Act No. 559, An Act to Amend Commonwealth Act Numbered One Hundred and Three, as Amended (June 7, 1940) — The LawPhil Project
- Commonwealth Act No. 559, An Act to Amend Commonwealth Act Numbered One Hundred and Three, as Amended (June 7, 1940) — Supreme Court E-Library
- Commonwealth Act No. 103, Creating the Court of Industrial Relations (October 29, 1936) — The LawPhil Project
- Commonwealth Act No. 461, An Act to Regulate the Relations Between Landowner and Tenant (June 9, 1939) — The LawPhil Project
- Ang Tibay v. Court of Industrial Relations, G.R. No. 46496 (February 27, 1940) — The LawPhil Project
- Republic Act No. 875, An Act to Promote Industrial Peace and for Other Purposes (June 17, 1953) — The LawPhil Project
- Presidential Decree No. 442 — The Labor Code of the Philippines (May 1, 1974) — The LawPhil Project